Home Case Laws Assistant Commissioner is not a proper officer to carry out search or...

Assistant Commissioner is not a proper officer to carry out search or inspection.

0
276

Case Title: Prakashsinh Hathisinh Udavat v. State of Gujarat

Court: High Court of Gujarat

Petition No.: Special Civil Application No. 15365 of 2019

Category: Search and Seizure under GST

Date of Judgment: 16 October 2019

Relevant Provisions: Sections 67(2), 71, 83, and 157 of the GGST Act, 2017; Rule 139 of the CGST Rules

Takeaway: Brute Seizure Without Authority: When Process Becomes Harassment

Facts of the Case [¶3–6, 8–9]

  • The petitioner’s car and two mobile phones were seized on 25.10.2018 under Section 67(2) of the GGST Act by the Assistant Commissioner (Enforcement), alleging fake ITC transactions amounting to ₹10–15 crores [¶4].
  • The petitioner claimed the seizure occurred without a proper authorisation or panchanama, and despite repeated oral and written representations, the goods were not released nor was any notice under Section 67(7) issued [¶5–6].
  • The seizure order bizarrely cited the search premises as “Rajya Kar Bhavan,” the office of the State Tax Department itself [¶13].
  • The respondent admitted that the seizure was carried out without specific authorisation by a Joint Commissioner, and justified the action by citing a larger GST fraud involving fake bills worth ₹13.33 crores [¶9–9.3].

 

Question(s) in Consideration [¶10–14]

  1. Whether the seizure of the petitioner’s property was legally valid under Section 67(2) of the GGST Act without proper authorisation by a competent officer?
  2. Whether the continued detention of the seized items violated the petitioner’s statutory and constitutional rights?

 

Observations of the Court [¶10–24]

  • Section 67(2) requires a proper officer not below the rank of Joint Commissioner to authorise search and seizure operations; no such authorisation existed in this case [¶10–14].
  • The search was allegedly conducted at “Rajya Kar Bhavan,” an absurdity that rendered the very basis of the seizure invalid [¶13].
  • Rule 139 of the CGST Rules was violated, especially as the seizure lacked an inventory and witness details [¶15].
  • The officer acted without authority, misusing power under the guise of protecting revenue, and his actions amounted to gross abuse of statutory power [¶16, ¶19].
  • Though the court considered awarding exemplary costs for harassment, it refrained due to the petitioner’s fear of reprisal from the department [¶24].

 

Judgment of the Court [¶25–27]

  • The High Court quashed the seizure order dated 25.10.2018 as illegal and without jurisdiction [¶25].
  • Ordered immediate release of the car and mobile phones [¶25].
  • Directed the registry to communicate the judgment to the Chief Secretary of the State for departmental corrective action [¶26].
  • Rule made absolute with costs, though exemplary costs were not imposed per petitioner’s request [¶27].

 

Between Fine Lines

  • Officers must adhere strictly to authorisation requirements under Section 67(2).
  • GST authorities cannot misuse powers of seizure without lawful basis.
  • A seizure order citing government premises as the searched site is absurd and untenable.
  • Lack of timely notice under Section 67(7) and improper documentation violates due process.
  • Fear of departmental retaliation prevents citizens from seeking appropriate redress or costs.

 

Summary of Referred Cases

Name of Case Citation Summary Verdict
No external case referred in the judgment — — —

 

LEAVE A REPLY