Case Title: H.M. Industrial (P.) Ltd. v. Commissioner, CGST and Central Excise
Court: High Court of Gujarat
Petition No.: Special Civil Application No. 1160 of 2019
Relevant Section: Section 83 and Section 89 of the CGST Act, 2017
Category of Dispute: Provisional Attachment under GST
Date of Judgement: 7 February 2019
Facts of the Case
- The petitioner, H.M. Industrial (P.) Ltd., was subjected to provisional attachment of properties under Section 83 of the CGST Act, including attachment of personal bank accounts of its directors. [Para 1]
- The petitioner contended that only the company, being a registered taxable person under the CGST Act, could be subjected to provisional attachment—not its individual directors. [Para 1]
- The respondent revenue relied on Section 89 of the CGST Act, arguing that the directors of a private company could be held liable for dues if the company fails to pay. [Para 2]
Question(s) in Consideration
- Whether Section 83 of the CGST Act allows for provisional attachment of personal bank accounts of directors of a company. [Para 1]
- Whether reliance on Section 89 for provisional attachment of directors’ bank accounts is legally valid at this stage. [Para 2]
Observations of the Court
- Section 83 authorizes provisional attachment of the property of a “taxable person” only, which is defined under Section 2(107) to mean a registered or liable person under Section 22 or 24. The petitioner-company is the taxable person, not the directors. [Para 1]
- Section 89 pertains to recovery from directors only if tax cannot be recovered from the company and if the director is found guilty of gross neglect, misfeasance, or breach of duty. This provision is not applicable at the provisional attachment stage. [Para 2]
- Hence, attachment of directors’ bank accounts was held to be without authority of law. [Para 2]
Judgement of the Court
- The court held that provisional attachment under Section 83 could not be made against the directors of the petitioner-company. [Para 2]
- Directed the respondents to immediately release the attachment of the listed bank accounts belonging to the directors of H.M. Industrial (P.) Ltd. [Para 2]
Between Fine Lines
- Directors’ personal accounts cannot be provisionally attached under Section 83.
- The term “taxable person” does not include directors individually.
- Section 89 can only be invoked for recovery, and under stringent conditions—not at the attachment stage.
- Revenue cannot use attachment as a coercive tool against individuals unless the law explicitly allows it.
- Relief granted by delinking personal liability from company dues at provisional stage.
Summary of Referred Cases
| Name of Case | Citation | Summary | Verdict |
| No external cases referred | — | The court did not rely on or refer to any other judicial precedents in its ruling | Not applicable |




