Home Case Laws National Calamity Contingent Duty, Education Cess and Secondary and Higher Education Cess...

National Calamity Contingent Duty, Education Cess and Secondary and Higher Education Cess are not “Duty of Excise” therefore, Assessee could not utilize CENVAT credit of duties paid on inputs to pay NCCD, EC and SHEC.

0
267

Hero Motocorp Ltd. vs Commissioner of Central Excise, Dehradun

High Court of Uttarakhand

Central Excise Appeal Nos. 14 to 18 & 23 of 2017

Category: CENVAT Credit, Exemption under Area Based Notification, Penalty under Section 11AC

Judgment Date: 11 January 2018

Relevant Sections: Section 3 & 5A of Central Excise Act, 1944; Section 11AC; Rule 6 of CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004; Notification No. 50/2003-CE

 

Facts of the Case

  1. The appellant, Hero Motocorp Ltd., manufactured motorcycles in Uttarakhand, a region covered under the area-based Exemption Notification No. 50/2003-CE, and claimed exemption from duty. [Para 2]
  2. While availing the exemption, the appellant did not pay National Calamity Contingent Duty (NCCD), Education Cess (EC), and Secondary & Higher Education Cess (SHEC) on their final product. [Para 2]
  3. Central Excise authorities issued show cause notices demanding NCCD, EC, SHEC along with interest and penalty under Section 11AC. The appellant contested the liability by citing exemption and alternatively sought to use CENVAT Credit of basic excise duty on inputs for paying these levies. [Paras 3-4]
  4. The Tribunal rejected these contentions and upheld the demand and penalty. The appellant preferred appeals before the High Court. [Para 4]

 

Questions in Consideration

  1. Whether NCCD, EC, and SHEC are “duties of excise” and thus covered under Notification No. 50/2003-CE? [Para 6]
  2. Whether Rule 6 of the CENVAT Credit Rules bars utilization of CENVAT credit of duties paid on inputs for payment of NCCD, EC, and SHEC on exempt final products? [Para 6]
  3. Whether penalties under Section 11AC are justified where the appellant had deposited duties and raised a bona fide legal claim? [Para 6]
  4. Whether the imposition of penalty was legally sustainable in absence of any misrepresentation or suppression by the appellant? [Para 6]

 

Observation of Court

  1. On Exemption Claim: The Court held that Notification No. 50/2003 grants exemption only from the “duty of excise” as understood under Section 3 of the Act, and not from NCCD, EC or SHEC, which are levied under separate Finance Acts. Thus, the exemption does not cover these levies. [Paras 21, 46]
  2. On Rule 6 of CCR: Since the final product was exempt from basic excise duty under Notification No. 50/2003, Rule 6 of CCR barred the utilization of CENVAT credit of duties paid on inputs for paying NCCD and cesses. [Paras 40-46]
  3. On Interpretation of “Duties of Excise”: The Court acknowledged that NCCD and the cesses are duties of excise but held that their exemption was not implicit under the Notification without explicit mention. The “whole of duty” in Rule 6 refers primarily to basic excise duty. [Paras 41-46]
  4. On Penalty under Section 11AC: The Court upheld that penalty is mandatory once the ingredients under Section 11AC are met. Since the appellant availed the exemption and did not pay applicable levies without sufficient basis, the penalty was legally valid. Reliance on earlier Tribunal decisions could not sustain their claim since those decisions were against Supreme Court’s Modi Rubber Ltd. ruling. [Paras 73-84]
  5. On Bona Fide CENVAT Credit Claim: However, the Court accepted that appellant’s alternative plea of utilizing CENVAT credit for payment of NCCD and cesses was a pure question of law and remitted this issue to the Tribunal for fresh examination concerning penalty. [Para 85]

 

Judgment of Court

The High Court ruled:

  • Exemption Notification No. 50/2003 does not cover NCCD, EC, and SHEC. [Para 46]
  • CENVAT credit cannot be used to pay these duties when the final product is exempt from basic duty. Rule 6 applies. [Paras 40-46]
  • Penalty under Section 11AC is sustainable given the appellant’s actions did not fall under bona fide interpretation of law. Tribunal’s orders are upheld. [Paras 77-84]
  • However, the issue of whether penalty is imposable in light of the bona fide CENVAT Credit claim is remanded to the Tribunal for fresh consideration. [Para 85]

 

Between Fine Lines

  • Exemption under Notification 50/2003-CE applies only to basic excise duty, not to NCCD or cesses.
  • Rule 6 of the CCR blocks use of input credit for exempted final products.
  • NCCD and cesses are duties of excise but not exempted unless explicitly stated.
  • Reliance on earlier Tribunal decisions was misplaced due to conflict with Supreme Court precedent.
  • Penalty remanded for reconsideration in light of appellant’s bona fide claim regarding CENVAT credit

 

Summary of Referred Cases

Name Citation Summary Verdict/Impact on Case
Modi Rubber Ltd. 1986 taxmann.com 537 (SC) “Duty of excise” in exemption notification refers only to basic duty under Section 3. Binding precedent; basis for rejecting broader exemption.
Toyota Kirloskar Motor (P.) Ltd. 2007 (217) ELT 403 (CESTAT – Bang.) Tribunal held NCCD covered by exemption. Overruled in light of Modi Rubber; not binding.
Tatra Trucks India Ltd. 2008 (227) ELT 269 (CESTAT – Chennai) NCCD is exempted under general exemption; followed Toyota Kirloskar. Not considered good law by High Court.
JBF Industries Ltd. 2009 (246) ELT 286 (CESTAT – Ahd.) Tribunal exempted NCCD for clearances to EOU. Viewed as distinguishable.
CCE v. Prag Bosimi Synthetics Ltd. 2014 (46) GST 127 (Gau.) Ruled against exemption of NCCD and cesses. Relied upon to reject exemption claim.
Bajaj Auto v. UOI 2017 (1) U.D. 375 Held that area-based exemptions do not cover NCCD/cesses. Reaffirmed narrow interpretation of exemption.
Union of India v. Dharmendra Textile 2008 (231) ELT 3 (SC) Penalty under Section 11AC is mandatory once ingredients are fulfilled. Relied upon for penalty justification.
UOI v. Rajasthan Spinning Mills [2009] 20 STT 481 (SC) Clarified that mens rea not essential once Section 11AC conditions are met. Reaffirmed penalty imposition.

LEAVE A REPLY