Case Title: Biharilal Chhaterpal v. State of Uttar Pradesh
Court: Allahabad High Court
Petition No.: Misc. Single No. 29323 of 2019
Category of Dispute: Penalty under Section 129 – Wrongful Seizure for E-way Bill Deficiency
Date of Judgement: 16 November 2021
Relevant Sections:
Section 129(3), U.P. GST Act, 2017
Section 20(xv), IGST Act, 2017
Sections 67, 68, CGST Act, 2017
Rule 138, CGST Rules, 2017
Facts of the Case
[Para 2, 5–8]
The petitioner challenged orders dated 26.02.2018 and 30.03.2019, passed under Section 129(3) of the U.P. GST Act and in appeal by the Additional Commissioner (Appeals), which imposed tax and penalty of ₹2,08,800 each on the ground of non-carrying of the U.P. e-way bill during interstate transport from Raipur (Chhattisgarh) to Sitapur (U.P.).
At the time of interception, the vehicle was carrying a tax invoice, bilty, national e-way bill, and later generated the state e-way bill at 2:49 AM on 19.02.2018.
[Para 14–15]
The tax (IGST @ 18%) had already been paid. All relevant documents, including tax invoice and national e-way bill, were available during transportation, evidencing bona fide movement.
Questions in Consideration
[Para 13, 16]
- Whether the U.P. GST authorities were justified in imposing penalty for not carrying a U.P. state e-way bill during interstate movement of goods?
- Was there a requirement of U.P. state e-way bill under the law at the time of interception (19.02.2018)?
- Whether the application of U.P. GST Act and Rules was legally sustainable in this interstate movement?
Observations of the Court
[Para 9–13, 16]
- The movement was an interstate supply; thus, governed by the IGST Act, 2017. Under Section 20(xv) of the IGST Act, provisions of CGST Act apply, not U.P. GST Act.
- Rule 138 of CGST Rules requires a notification by the Central Government for e-way bill enforcement. No such notification existed on the date of transport (19.02.2018).
- The petitioner was carrying valid documents as required and generated the state e-way bill shortly thereafter. The transaction was bona fide and not an attempt to evade tax.
- Referring to Satyendra Goods Transport Corp. v. State of U.P., Godrej & Boyce Mfg. Co. Ltd., Shaurya Enterprises, and Mudassisun Nisan, the Court reaffirmed that state authorities cannot enforce their own Rule 138 in case of interstate transport.
Judgement of the Court
[Para 20–22]
- The orders dated 26.02.2018 and 30.03.2019 passed under Section 129(3) of U.P. GST Act were quashed.
- The Court directed a refund of the amount deposited as tax and penalty within two months.
- Writ petition was allowed in favour of the petitioner.
Between Fine Lines
This judgment clarifies that during interstate transport of goods, only IGST provisions apply. The state-specific e-way bill requirement under U.P. GST Act was not enforceable before 1st April 2018. The case emphasizes that mere technical lapses, especially when tax is already paid and all substantial documents are in place, do not justify penalty under Section 129.
Summary of Referred Cases
| Case Name | Citation | Summary | Verdict |
| Satyendra Goods Transport Corp. v. State of U.P. | [2018] 92 taxmann.com 209 | Held that U.P. GST Act provisions are not applicable to interstate transport; e-way bill not mandatory. | Relief granted to petitioner |
| Godrej & Boyce Mfg. Co. Ltd. v. State of U.P. | [2018] 97 taxmann.com 552 | Reiterated that U.P. GST law cannot be invoked for interstate transactions. | Orders under U.P. GST quashed |
| Mudassisun Nisan v. Addl. Commissioner (Appeals) | [2020] 113 taxmann.com 224 | Relied on earlier Division Bench rulings to quash similar penalty under Section 129. | Similar orders quashed |
| Shaurya Enterprises v. State of U.P. | [2018] 99 taxmann.com 48 | Court held e-way bill was not mandatory until 1-4-2018 under CGST/UPGST Act. | Proceedings under U.P. GST Act invalidated |
| ASCICS Trading Company v. Asst. State Tax Officer | 2017 NTN (Vol.65) 145 | Kerala HC held that without Central notification, e-way bill non-compliance cannot be penalized. | Detention found illegal; writ petition allowed |
Takeaway:
“Inter-State, Not Interceptable: No U.P. E-way Bill Needed Pre-April 2018”




