Case Title: V.N. Mehta & Company v. Assistant Commissioner, Nungambakkam, Chennai
Court: High Court of Madras
Petition No.: W.P. No. 26187 of 2019, W.M.P. Nos. 25551 to 25553 of 2019
Category: Recovery Proceedings without Assessment
Date of Judgement: 08 November 2019
Relevant Sections: Sections 74, 79, and 83 of CGST Act, 2017
Issue: Invocation of recovery proceedings without adjudication under CGST
Facts of the Case (Paras 1–5)
- The writ petition challenged recovery proceedings dated 07.08.2019 issued under Section 79 of the CGST Act for ₹53,28,645, directing the bank to debit the petitioner’s account towards alleged tax, cess, interest, and penalty dues. (Para 1)
- The petitioner claimed that no adjudication or show cause notice had been issued under any provision of the CGST Act prior to invoking recovery, making the action premature and illegal. (Para 2)
- A GST Superintendent had recorded a statement from the petitioner on 19.06.2019, allegedly admitting ITC on fake invoices; however, the petitioner retracted this statement on 26.06.2019 asserting that goods were received along with invoices. (Paras 2–3)
- Respondents relied on the petitioner’s initial “admission” and contended that no show cause was necessary, citing Section 79 CGST Act. They also attempted to invoke Section 83 for revenue protection. (Paras 4–5)
- The Court enquired whether any proceedings under Sections 62, 63, 64, 67, 73 or 74 were pending; the respondent admitted that none were. (Para 5)
Questions in Consideration (Para 6)
- Whether recovery proceedings under Section 79 of the CGST Act can be initiated without determination of tax liability through adjudication?
- Whether provisional attachment under Section 83 is permissible without any pending proceedings?
Observations of the Court (Paras 7–13)
- Section 79 requires a determined and payable liability before recovery steps can be initiated. No such determination had occurred in this case. (Para 7)
- The so-called admission by the petitioner in answer to Question 13 was contradicted by answer to Question 17 and later retracted through written communication. (Paras 8–9)
- Therefore, there was no valid admission on record to treat the amount as an admitted liability. (Para 10)
- The Court noted that invoking Section 83 for provisional attachment requires pendency of proceedings under Sections 62, 63, 64, 67, 73, or 74, which was admittedly absent. (Paras 12–13)
Judgement of the Court (Para 14)
- The High Court held that the invocation of Section 79 and issuance of recovery proceedings was unsustainable in law without adjudication.
- It quashed the impugned proceedings and allowed the writ petition.
- It clarified that it was not commenting on the merits of the allegations and that proceedings could be initiated afresh in accordance with law.
Between Fine Lines
- Recovery under GST cannot be invoked without determining liability through due process.
- A retracted statement cannot be used as conclusive admission for recovery.
- Section 79 demands a concluded adjudication or assessment before enforcement.
- Provisional attachment under Section 83 requires a pending proceeding, not mere suspicion.
- Tax authorities must follow statutory safeguards before coercive actions.
Summary of Referred Cases
No specific case law cited or relied upon in this judgment by either party.
Takeaway
“No Recovery Without Assessment: Admission Once Retracted is No Admission in Law”




