Home Case Laws Show Cause Notice is necessarily to be issued electronically and correspondingly passing...

Show Cause Notice is necessarily to be issued electronically and correspondingly passing demand order immediately after postal notice, Order be liable to Quashed.

0
217

Case Title: Jabir Hasan v. Assistant Commissioner of State Tax GST

Court: High Court of Uttarakhand

Petition No.: WPMS No. 1547 of 2021

Relevant Section: Rule 68 of CGST Rules, 2017

Category of Dispute: Non-filing of Returns / Procedural Lapse

Date of Judgement: 10 November 2021

Relevant Provision: Rule 68 of CGST Rules, 2017 (Notice to non-filers of returns)

 

Facts of the Case (¶4–7)

  1. Petitioner’s Default: Jabir Hasan, a GST registrant, failed to file GST returns, which triggered proceedings against him (¶5).
  2. SCN & Orders: A show cause notice was issued, followed by an adverse order by the tax authority dated 28-09-2019. The appeal against this order was dismissed on 26-06-2021 (¶5).
  3. Mode of Notice: As per the petitioner, notice was not served in the electronic form as mandated under Rule 68. Instead, a physical postal notice was sent (¶6–7).
  4. State’s Admission: The State admitted that no electronic notice in Form GSTR-3A was issued under Rule 68, only postal notice was sent (¶7).

 

Question(s) in Consideration (¶4, ¶8)

  • Whether the proceedings under GST law for non-filing of returns and the consequential orders are valid when electronic notice under Rule 68 of the CGST Rules, 2017 was not issued?

 

Observation of Court (¶8)

  1. The Court reiterated the principle that when a statute prescribes a specific procedure, it must be strictly followed.
  2. The issuance of postal notice, instead of electronic notice as required by Rule 68 (using Form GSTR-3A), amounted to a procedural illegality.
  3. The absence of electronic notice vitiated the entire proceedings leading to the impugned orders.

 

Judgement of the Court (¶9)

  • The High Court quashed the orders dated 26-06-2021 and 28-09-2019 passed by the tax authorities.
  • The case was remanded back to the authority with directions to strictly comply with Rule 68 and reconsider the matter afresh.

 

Between Fine Lines

  • The case emphasizes that procedural compliance, especially when mandated by the law, is not a mere formality but a legal obligation.
  • Sending a postal notice instead of an electronic notice under Rule 68 renders the proceedings invalid.
  • Taxpayers have the right to be notified through the prescribed means before punitive measures are taken.
  • Authorities must adhere strictly to procedural rules to uphold the validity of their actions.
  • This case strengthens the accountability of tax departments to follow due process under GST law.

 

Summary of Referred Cases

Name of Case Citation Summary Verdict
None cited – No judicial precedents were cited in this case. –

 

Takeaway

“Procedure Prescribed Is Procedure Mandated – No Shortcuts in GST Notices”

LEAVE A REPLY