Case Title: Jabir Hasan v. Assistant Commissioner of State Tax GST
Court: High Court of Uttarakhand
Petition No.: WPMS No. 1547 of 2021
Relevant Section: Rule 68 of CGST Rules, 2017
Category of Dispute: Non-filing of Returns / Procedural Lapse
Date of Judgement: 10 November 2021
Relevant Provision: Rule 68 of CGST Rules, 2017 (Notice to non-filers of returns)
Facts of the Case (¶4–7)
- Petitioner’s Default: Jabir Hasan, a GST registrant, failed to file GST returns, which triggered proceedings against him (¶5).
- SCN & Orders: A show cause notice was issued, followed by an adverse order by the tax authority dated 28-09-2019. The appeal against this order was dismissed on 26-06-2021 (¶5).
- Mode of Notice: As per the petitioner, notice was not served in the electronic form as mandated under Rule 68. Instead, a physical postal notice was sent (¶6–7).
- State’s Admission: The State admitted that no electronic notice in Form GSTR-3A was issued under Rule 68, only postal notice was sent (¶7).
Question(s) in Consideration (¶4, ¶8)
- Whether the proceedings under GST law for non-filing of returns and the consequential orders are valid when electronic notice under Rule 68 of the CGST Rules, 2017 was not issued?
Observation of Court (¶8)
- The Court reiterated the principle that when a statute prescribes a specific procedure, it must be strictly followed.
- The issuance of postal notice, instead of electronic notice as required by Rule 68 (using Form GSTR-3A), amounted to a procedural illegality.
- The absence of electronic notice vitiated the entire proceedings leading to the impugned orders.
Judgement of the Court (¶9)
- The High Court quashed the orders dated 26-06-2021 and 28-09-2019 passed by the tax authorities.
- The case was remanded back to the authority with directions to strictly comply with Rule 68 and reconsider the matter afresh.
Between Fine Lines
- The case emphasizes that procedural compliance, especially when mandated by the law, is not a mere formality but a legal obligation.
- Sending a postal notice instead of an electronic notice under Rule 68 renders the proceedings invalid.
- Taxpayers have the right to be notified through the prescribed means before punitive measures are taken.
- Authorities must adhere strictly to procedural rules to uphold the validity of their actions.
- This case strengthens the accountability of tax departments to follow due process under GST law.
Summary of Referred Cases
| Name of Case | Citation | Summary | Verdict |
| None cited | – | No judicial precedents were cited in this case. | – |
Takeaway
“Procedure Prescribed Is Procedure Mandated – No Shortcuts in GST Notices”




