Case Title: Imperial Dyeing Ltd. v. State of Gujarat
Court: High Court of Gujarat
Petition No.: R/Special Civil Application No. 4848 of 2021
Category: Transitional Credit / Jurisdictional Challenge / Natural Justice
Date of Judgement: 17th November 2021
Relevant Sections:
Section 18(1)(d), 140(1) of CGST Act, 2017
Gujarat Value Added Tax Act, 2003
Facts of the Case
[Para 1–2.2]
The petitioner, Imperial Dyeing Ltd., is engaged in dyeing and printing of fabrics on job work basis and was registered under the VAT Act before GST came into force. It purchased capital goods (machinery) between April and June 2017 for manufacturing exempted goods under VAT, which became taxable under GST. The petitioner claimed transitional credit of VAT paid on such capital goods via Form TRAN-1 under GST, asserting that the input tax credit (ITC) was eligible under Section 18(1)(d) of CGST Act and remained unutilized under the VAT regime.
[Para 3–3.1]
A VAT assessment for Q1 of FY 2017–18 resulted in the Assistant Commissioner disallowing the transitional credit claimed under GST, and raised tax demands, interest, and penalties under the VAT Act via an order dated 12-1-2021—without issuing a show cause notice or granting a hearing regarding the credit.
[Para 4]
The petitioner contended that the VAT authorities lacked jurisdiction to adjudicate transitional credit issues governed by GST law and that such disallowance without hearing violated principles of natural justice.
Questions in Consideration
[Para 4 & 5]
- Whether VAT authorities have jurisdiction to disallow transitional credit claimed under the CGST Act?
- Whether transitional credit of capital goods used for taxable goods under GST is eligible under Section 18(1)(d) and 140(1) of CGST Act?
- Whether disallowance of such credit without issuing notice and hearing violates principles of natural justice?
Observations of the Court
[Para 7–8]
- The Revenue acknowledged no separate notice under Section 140 of the GST Act was issued during the VAT assessment.
- The Court observed that disallowance of transitional credit—when the same remains unutilized in the electronic credit ledger—without giving an opportunity of hearing is improper.
- Since the core issue was procedural (lack of hearing), the merits of the transitional credit claim were not examined.
Judgement of the Court
[Para 9–10]
- The Gujarat High Court quashed the order dated 12-1-2021 passed by the Assistant Commissioner solely on the ground of violation of natural justice.
- The matter was remanded to the same officer for fresh adjudication after granting opportunity of hearing to the petitioner.
- Any additional documents could be filed within one week; the hearing to be completed within four weeks thereafter.
Between Fine Lines
This case reinforces that transitional credit disputes under GST cannot be adjudicated under the VAT regime without due process. A VAT officer cannot disallow GST transitional credit without issuing proper notice and hearing. Procedural fairness was prioritized over legal merits. The matter was remanded for reconsideration, preserving the petitioner’s right to defend the transitional credit.
Summary of Referred Cases
(No specific precedents cited by either party in this case.)
Takeaway:
“Jurisdiction Ends Where New Law Begins: VAT Officer Cannot Deny GST Transitional Credit Without Due Process”




