Home Case Laws Input Tax Credit would not be available for the period from date...

Input Tax Credit would not be available for the period from date of commencement of business until Registration is granted.

0
204

Case Title: V.K. Cement & Steels v. State of Kerala

Court: High Court of Kerala

Petition No.: OT Rev. No. 22 of 2015

Date of Judgement: January 9, 2018

Relevant Section: Section 16(2) of the Kerala Value Added Tax Act, 2003

Category of Dispute: Input Tax Credit

 

Facts of the Case

  1. The assessee commenced business on 2-2-2006, applied for registration on 28-2-2006, and was granted a registration certificate retrospectively effective from 8-2-2006 [¶2].
  2. The assessee claimed Input Tax Credit (ITC) for the period from 2-2-2006 to 8-2-2006, arguing that business had already commenced, though registration was granted later [¶1].
  3. The department denied the claim on grounds that under the then-existing first proviso to Section 16(2), ITC was available only from the date of registration, not from the date of commencement of business [¶3].

Question(s) in Consideration

Whether the assessee is entitled to input tax credit for purchases made between the date of commencement of business and the date of registration, relying on the first proviso to Section 16(2) and judicial precedents such as STO v. Kerala Curry House? [¶1]

Observations of the Court

  1. As per the then-effective proviso to Section 16(2), registration could only be from the date of filing the application, not from the actual commencement of business [¶3].
  2. The court clarified that any discrepancy with the registration date could have been challenged via appeal or writ but wasn’t done [¶3].
  3. The 2009 amendment to Section 16(2) (via Kerala Finance Act) allowing deemed registration from the date of commencement was held to apply only for:
    a. Payment of presumptive tax under Section 6(5), and
    b. Option for tax under Section 8 [¶4, ¶7].
  4. Citing K.K. Abraham & Co. v. STO, the court held that input tax credit requires actual registration as per Section 11 and not merely business commencement [¶8–9].
  5. The court found that Kerala Curry House did not support the petitioner’s stand as the amendment had not come into effect at the time of registration, and correction of registration date was not pursued properly [¶3, ¶8].

 

Judgement of the Court

The High Court dismissed the revision petition, holding that input tax credit is not available for the period prior to registration. It affirmed that retrospective benefit under amended Section 16(2) does not extend to input tax credit, and applies only for presumptive or composition tax purposes under Sections 6(5) and 8 [¶9].

           

Between Fine Lines

  • Input Tax Credit is strictly contingent on actual registration under KVAT.
  • Mere commencement of business does not qualify a dealer for ITC.
  • Amendments made in 2009 granting retrospective registration are not applicable to ITC.
  • Court underscores the importance of challenging registration dates if incorrect.
  • K.K. Abraham and Kerala Curry House were distinguished and clarified on scope.

Summary of Referred Cases

Name of Case Citation Summary Verdict in Case
STO v. Kerala Curry House 2010 (3) KLT 26 (SN) Dealt with registration correction; held corrections not permissible post-facto. Not applicable to retrospective ITC claims.
K.K. Abraham & Co. v. STO [2013] 64 VST 122 (Ker.) Held that registration is deemed from commencement only for Sections 6(5) and 8 purposes, not for ITC. Followed and affirmed in current judgment.

 

Download Judgement

LEAVE A REPLY