Home Case Laws Input Tax Credit was reversed due to Non-Capacity of the vehicles and...

Input Tax Credit was reversed due to Non-Capacity of the vehicles and in absence of sufficient documents to substantiate the claim.

0
232

Case Title: Mangalam Alloys Ltd. vs. Commissioner of Central Excise, Ahmedabad-III

Court: High Court of Gujarat

Petition Number: R/Tax Appeal Nos. 1088 and 1089 of 2018

Category of Dispute: Cenvat Credit – Denial of Input Credit

Date of Judgment: September 5, 2018

Relevant Sections: Cenvat Credit Rules, Central Excise Act, 1944

 

Facts of the Case:

  1. The appellant, Mangalam Alloys Ltd., a manufacturer, availed Cenvat credit amounting to ₹5,89,667 based on 12 invoices for inputs claimed to have been received from M/s. Goodluck Empire and M/s. Jenil Empire, Bhavnagar [Para 3].
  2. Upon investigation, the department obtained an RTO report indicating that the vehicles mentioned in these invoices (like auto-rickshaws and three-wheelers) were incapable of transporting the declared quantities of goods [Para 4].
  3. Statements recorded from supplier representatives did not satisfactorily explain the discrepancies and were never retracted; the assessee too failed to clarify, merely stating the transportation responsibility was on the suppliers as goods were ordered on an FOR basis [Para 4].
  4. The Tribunal, relying on these findings and the precedent in Gyscoal Alloys Ltd. v. CCE [2014] 41 taxmann.com 533 (Guj.), upheld the denial of credit and imposition of penalty [Para 4].

 

Questions in Consideration:

(a) Whether the Tribunal was justified in denying Cenvat credit for 12 invoices based on adverse inference, despite no issues with 4686 other invoices? [Para 2]
(b) Whether denial of credit without corroborative evidence of non-receipt of inputs was legal? [Para 2]
(c) Whether the penalty imposed on the appellant and its representative was justified under the facts? [Para 2]

 

 

Observations of the Court:

  1. The High Court noted that the Tribunal’s conclusions were based on concrete findings such as the unchallenged RTO report and unexplained statements by suppliers and the appellant’s representative [Para 5].
  2. It emphasized that the burden to disprove the evidence (RTO report, vehicle incapacity) was on the assessee, especially when such vehicles could not have transported the goods [Para 5].
  3. The plea that the Tribunal acted merely on presumptions was dismissed—its findings were evidence-based and not arbitrary [Para 6].
  4. The argument that other similar invoices were accepted was held immaterial, as each case must be judged on its own merits and evidentiary backing [Para 6].

 

Judgment of the Court:

  • The High Court dismissed the tax appeal, affirming the Tribunal’s order. It held that no substantial question of law arose and that the Tribunal’s finding that goods were not received was not perverse or unfounded [Para 7].

 

Between Fine Lines:

  • If invoice details suggest implausible transportation (e.g., heavy goods shown as transported in rickshaws), input credit may be denied.
  • FOR terms do not absolve the assessee from proving actual receipt of goods when questioned.
  • Statements by suppliers and RTO reports carry strong evidentiary value if not rebutted.
  • Each invoice must be defended on its own merit; past acceptance of others does not assure current credibility.
  • Courts will not entertain appeals on purely factual disputes if supported by robust evidence.

 

Summary of Referred Cases:

Name of Case Citation Summary Verdict
Gyscoal Alloys Ltd. v. CCE [2014] 41 taxmann.com 533 / 43 GST 506 (Guj.) Held that Cenvat credit can be denied if it is established that goods were not received by the assessee. Relied upon by Tribunal to uphold denial of credit

 

LEAVE A REPLY