Home Updates Parshwa Investment v. DCIT: ITAT Mumbai Quashes Reassessment Initiated Under Section 147

Parshwa Investment v. DCIT: ITAT Mumbai Quashes Reassessment Initiated Under Section 147

0
98

The Mumbai Bench of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) has delivered an important ruling on the interplay between Sections 147 and 153C of the Income-tax Act, 1961 in Parshwa Investment v. Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax, Central Circle-7(1). The Tribunal held that where reassessment is founded entirely on material unearthed during a search conducted on a third party, the Revenue cannot invoke Section 147 and must instead follow the special procedure prescribed under Section 153C.

The assessee challenged the reassessment proceedings initiated under Section 147 for Assessment Year 2018-19. The reopening was based on information obtained from a search conducted on the Oneworld Group, during which statements and documents allegedly indicated that certain accommodation entries had been routed through entities connected with the assessee. Based on this material, the Assessing Officer made additions under Sections 68 and 69C relating to unsecured loans and interest expenditure. The assessee raised an additional legal ground before the Tribunal contending that, since the entire information originated from a third-party search, proceedings ought to have been initiated under Section 153C instead of Section 147.

The Tribunal accepted the additional legal ground and observed that Section 153C provides a special statutory mechanism where documents or information relating to a person other than the searched person are found during search proceedings. Once the conditions of Section 153C are attracted, the Assessing Officer cannot bypass that provision by resorting to reassessment under Section 147. The Tribunal relied upon its earlier decision in DCIT v. Ghanshyam Rasiklal Shah and the Bombay High Court judgment in Sejal Jewellery v. Union of India, reiterating that Sections 153A and 153C constitute a complete code for assessments arising out of search proceedings.

The Tribunal further noted that the Revenue itself admitted that the information relied upon emanated from the material seized during the search of the Oneworld Group. Since the reassessment was founded entirely on such search material, the jurisdiction assumed under Section 147 was held to be contrary to the statutory scheme. Consequently, the notice issued under Section 148 and the reassessment proceedings were declared void ab initio. Having allowed the jurisdictional challenge, the Tribunal did not examine the additions made on merits under Sections 68 and 69C.

This decision reinforces the principle that where the Income Tax Department seeks to assess a person on the basis of documents or information discovered during a search conducted on another person, it must strictly comply with the mandatory procedure prescribed under Section 153C. The ruling also reiterates that the special provisions governing search assessments override the general reassessment provisions contained in Section 147.

The judgment will be particularly relevant for tax professionals dealing with reassessment notices arising from search and seizure operations, jurisdictional challenges, and litigation involving Sections 147, 148, 148A and 153C of the Income-tax Act.

LEAVE A REPLY