Home Case Laws Amendment in GSTR-1 was allowed due to inadvertent mistake which deprive genuine...

Amendment in GSTR-1 was allowed due to inadvertent mistake which deprive genuine buyers from availing Input Tax Credit.

0
354

Case Title: Vadehra Builders (P.) Ltd. v. Union of India

Court: High Court of Delhi

Petition No.: W.P. (C) No. 9963 of 2019

Category of Dispute: Input Tax Credit – Rectification of GSTR-1

Date of Order: 14 November 2019

Relevant Section: Section 37(3) of the CGST Act, 2017; Rule 59(4) of CGST Rules, 2017

 

Facts of the Case (¶1–4):

  1. The petitioner, Vadehra Builders Pvt. Ltd., sold goods (paintings) in November 2017 and filed GSTR-1 returns for that month. However, due to an inadvertent mistake, incorrect GSTINs were reported against six invoices (¶2–3).
  2. The total amount involved in these supplies was significant, and the associated input tax credit (ITC) was ₹19,07,437 (¶3).
  3. The mistake in GSTIN entry led to a mismatch, potentially depriving actual buyers of rightful ITC, due to the GSTR-2 not being operationalized at that time (¶4).
  4. Despite repeated opportunities, the respondent (Union of India/GST Department) failed to file a reply. The petitioner, citing urgency due to the approaching annual return deadline (30.11.2019), sought permission to file a rectified GSTR-1 manually (¶1, ¶6).

 

Questions in Consideration (¶2, ¶5):

  1. Whether the petitioner should be permitted to rectify Form GSTR-1 for November 2017 manually to correct recipient GSTINs?
  2. Whether failure of the respondents in activating GSTR-2 justified allowing manual rectification of GSTR-1?

 

Observations of the Court (¶5–6):

  1. The Court took cognizance of the decision in Panduranga Stone Crushers v. Union of India (Andhra Pradesh High Court), where similar rectification was allowed in GSTR-3B filings (¶5).
  2. The Court noted the respondent’s failure to file a reply since 16.09.2019, despite sufficient time. The urgency of the petitioner’s situation, as the return deadline loomed, was accepted as a valid ground for interim relief (¶6).

 

Judgement of the Court (¶6–7):

  1. The petitioner was permitted to rectify the GSTR-1 for November 2017 manually by correcting the GSTINs of the six recipients mentioned, within one week (¶6).
  2. The respondents were directed to verify the status and proceed in accordance with law. Additionally, they were granted 8 weeks to file a counter affidavit, with rejoinder to follow before the next hearing (¶6–7).

 

Between Fine Lines

  • The Court allowed manual rectification of GSTR-1 to correct GSTIN errors where GSTR-2 was not enabled.
  • It acknowledged that recipient taxpayers could lose ITC due to unintentional errors in return filing.
  • Interim relief was granted even though the main writ was pending, based on urgency and non-reply by authorities.
  • The judgment illustrates judicial pragmatism in early GST implementation issues.
  • It sets precedent for permitting rectification when technical constraints prevent proper filing.

 

Summary of Referred Cases

Name Citation Summary Verdict
Panduranga Stone Crushers v. Union of India I.A. No. 01/2019 in W.P. 8662/2019, Andhra Pradesh HC Permitted rectification of GSTR-3B for specific months where error was unintentional. Rectification allowed, subject to final outcome.

 

Takeaway:

“Correcting the Code: GST Return Rectification Allowed for Clerical GSTIN Errors”

LEAVE A REPLY