Home Case Laws Appeal remedy directed as Delhi HC held no violation of natural justice...

Appeal remedy directed as Delhi HC held no violation of natural justice where ITC demand was raised and personal hearings were duly offered but not availed

0
208

Case Summary

Case Title: Bharat Fabrex v. Additional Commissioner, CGST Delhi North & Ors.
Court: Delhi High Court
Petition No.: W.P.(C) 10918/2025 & CM Appl. 45016/2025, 45017/2025
Category of Dispute: Input Tax Credit (ITC) – Wrongful availment on goods-less invoices
Date of Judgment: 28 July 2025
Relevant Section: Section 107 of CGST Act, 2017 (Appeal to Appellate Authority)

Facts (Paras 3–6)

The petitioner challenged an Order-in-Original dated 4 February 2025 raising a demand of around ₹6.5 lakh as part of a larger alleged wrongful ITC claim of ₹12.90 crore spread across 161 entities, involving goods-less invoices issued by five non-existent suppliers—City Overseas, Delhi Trading, Global Enterprises, Royal International, and Yamuna International.
Out of these, 47 entities, including the petitioner, reversed ITC and deposited amounts voluntarily. The petitioner deposited ₹6,50,860/– but claimed it was under protest. The grievance raised was that no personal hearing was granted.


Questions in Dispute (Paras 3–7)

  1. Whether the demand was liable to be set aside for want of personal hearing and violation of natural justice?

  2. Whether the petitioner, having deposited the tax under protest, could directly challenge the order in writ jurisdiction instead of filing appeal under Section 107 of CGST Act?

  3. Whether the order was beyond limitation, since it was dated 4 February 2025 but uploaded only on 12 February 2025?


Observations of the Court (Paras 7–10)

  • The Court noted that personal hearings were indeed scheduled on 8 November 2024, 6 December 2024, and 9 December 2024, and many firms appeared and made submissions. However, the petitioner failed to avail the opportunity. Hence, no violation of principles of natural justice could be established.

  • Since the petitioner had already made the deposit, though under protest, the matter was more appropriate for an appellate remedy under Section 107, rather than invoking writ jurisdiction.

  • On the plea that the order was uploaded late, the Court held that the petitioner may raise such a plea before the Appellate Authority.


Judgment (Paras 8–11)

The Delhi High Court disposed of the writ petition holding that:

  • There was no breach of natural justice.

  • The petitioner is to be relegated to the statutory appeal under Section 107, and if filed by 31 August 2025, it will be entertained on merits without being dismissed on limitation.

  • All pending applications were also disposed of.


Case Law Table (Referred Cases – This Order did not cite other precedents)

Case Name Citation Ratio / Verdict
No other precedents cited in this order – The Court confined itself to the petitioner’s case and Section 107 remedy.

Between Fine Lines (Practical Takeaway)

This ruling reiterates that writ jurisdiction will not ordinarily be entertained against GST adjudication orders where personal hearings were offered but not availed. Taxpayers who have already deposited amounts under protest must pursue the statutory appellate remedy under Section 107, which remains the proper forum for raising issues like limitation, legality of demand, and validity of uploading orders.

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY