Home Case Laws Assessee was allowed to pay his statutory dues from the provisional attachment...

Assessee was allowed to pay his statutory dues from the provisional attachment bank accounts.

0
438

Case Title: SPNN Business Services (P.) Ltd. v. Commissioner of Central Tax (GST), Delhi

Court: High Court of Delhi

Petition No.: W.P. (C) No. 2435 of 2021, CM No. 7083 of 2021

Date of Judgement: 5 March 2021

Category of Dispute: Provisional Attachment under Section 83

Relevant Section: Section 83 of CGST Act, 2017

 

Takeaway:

“When Provisional Attachment Freezes Salaries: A Judicial Balance Between Revenue Interest and Employee Welfare”

Facts of the Case [¶1–2.1]

  1. The petitioner, SPNN Business Services (P.) Ltd., was aggrieved by the provisional attachment of its 11 bank accounts under Section 83 of the CGST Act dated 09.02.2021 [¶2].
  2. Due to the attachment, the petitioner could not operate its accounts, impacting payment of salaries to 14,600 employees [¶1.2, ¶2].
  3. The petitioner had submitted objections to the attachment, which were rejected on 18.02.2021 [¶2.1].
  4. Petitioner had paid ₹7.70 crores prior to 03.03.2021 against the alleged liability of ₹24.96 crores, reducing the principal outstanding to ₹17.26 crores and interest to ₹2.96 crores [¶3.1–3.2].
  5. Petitioner directors filed affidavits declaring the details of employees and the readiness to deposit title deeds of five immovable properties [¶1.1–1.4].

Question(s) in Consideration [¶3]

  1. Whether the provisional attachment of 11 bank accounts under Section 83 of the CGST Act was justified in the absence of any completed assessment.
  2. Whether relief can be granted to allow the company to disburse salaries and statutory dues despite pending dues and attachment.

Observations of the Court [¶3.3–3.4]

  1. No assessment had been made by the revenue, nor had the petitioner filed a self-assessment [¶3].
  2. The attachment was causing undue hardship to employees whose salaries were blocked [¶2].
  3. The court noted ₹5.80 crores were available across the 11 accounts, and directed a balance between employee welfare and safeguarding revenue interest [¶3.3(ii)].
  4. It acknowledged the bona fides shown by the petitioner via prior payment of ₹7.70 crores and readiness to deposit title deeds [¶3.3(v)].

 

Judgement of the Court [¶3.3–3.4, ¶5]

  1. Attachment lifted: The Court lifted the provisional attachment on all 11 bank accounts [¶3.3(i)].
  2. Monetary directions:
    • Petitioner to retain ₹2 crores in the bank accounts for salary payments [¶3.3(ii)].
    • Balance amount (approx. ₹3.80 crores) to be deposited with the revenue [¶3.3(ii)].
    • First tranche of ₹5 crores to be deposited separately by 31.03.2021 [¶3.3(iii)].
  3. Security measures: Original title deeds of 5 immovable properties to be deposited within two days [¶3.3(v)].
  4. Contingent enforcement: In case of default, revenue is permitted to proceed with sale of properties and take further steps against the petitioner or directors [¶3.3(vi–vii)].
  5. Usage of ₹2 crores: Limited to employee salary disbursement only [¶5].

 

Between Fine Lines:

  • The High Court balanced administrative enforcement under GST with humanitarian concerns for thousands of employees.
  • It lifted the provisional attachment conditionally to allow salaries while securing the revenue’s interests.
  • The court acknowledged the petitioner’s bona fide conduct and partial payment of dues.
  • The directions included time-bound monetary deposits and lien over immovable assets.
  • This case is a precedent on proportional use of provisional attachment powers under Section 83.

 

Summary of Referred Cases

Name Citation Summary Verdict
No case laws were expressly cited or discussed in the judgement — — —

 

LEAVE A REPLY