Case Title: SPNN Business Services (P.) Ltd. v. Commissioner of Central Tax (GST), Delhi
Court: High Court of Delhi
Petition No.: W.P. (C) No. 2435 of 2021, CM No. 7083 of 2021
Date of Judgement: 5 March 2021
Category of Dispute: Provisional Attachment under Section 83
Relevant Section: Section 83 of CGST Act, 2017
Takeaway:
“When Provisional Attachment Freezes Salaries: A Judicial Balance Between Revenue Interest and Employee Welfare”
Facts of the Case [¶1–2.1]
- The petitioner, SPNN Business Services (P.) Ltd., was aggrieved by the provisional attachment of its 11 bank accounts under Section 83 of the CGST Act dated 09.02.2021 [¶2].
- Due to the attachment, the petitioner could not operate its accounts, impacting payment of salaries to 14,600 employees [¶1.2, ¶2].
- The petitioner had submitted objections to the attachment, which were rejected on 18.02.2021 [¶2.1].
- Petitioner had paid ₹7.70 crores prior to 03.03.2021 against the alleged liability of ₹24.96 crores, reducing the principal outstanding to ₹17.26 crores and interest to ₹2.96 crores [¶3.1–3.2].
- Petitioner directors filed affidavits declaring the details of employees and the readiness to deposit title deeds of five immovable properties [¶1.1–1.4].
Question(s) in Consideration [¶3]
- Whether the provisional attachment of 11 bank accounts under Section 83 of the CGST Act was justified in the absence of any completed assessment.
- Whether relief can be granted to allow the company to disburse salaries and statutory dues despite pending dues and attachment.
Observations of the Court [¶3.3–3.4]
- No assessment had been made by the revenue, nor had the petitioner filed a self-assessment [¶3].
- The attachment was causing undue hardship to employees whose salaries were blocked [¶2].
- The court noted ₹5.80 crores were available across the 11 accounts, and directed a balance between employee welfare and safeguarding revenue interest [¶3.3(ii)].
- It acknowledged the bona fides shown by the petitioner via prior payment of ₹7.70 crores and readiness to deposit title deeds [¶3.3(v)].
Judgement of the Court [¶3.3–3.4, ¶5]
- Attachment lifted: The Court lifted the provisional attachment on all 11 bank accounts [¶3.3(i)].
- Monetary directions:
- Petitioner to retain ₹2 crores in the bank accounts for salary payments [¶3.3(ii)].
- Balance amount (approx. ₹3.80 crores) to be deposited with the revenue [¶3.3(ii)].
- First tranche of ₹5 crores to be deposited separately by 31.03.2021 [¶3.3(iii)].
- Security measures: Original title deeds of 5 immovable properties to be deposited within two days [¶3.3(v)].
- Contingent enforcement: In case of default, revenue is permitted to proceed with sale of properties and take further steps against the petitioner or directors [¶3.3(vi–vii)].
- Usage of ₹2 crores: Limited to employee salary disbursement only [¶5].
Between Fine Lines:
- The High Court balanced administrative enforcement under GST with humanitarian concerns for thousands of employees.
- It lifted the provisional attachment conditionally to allow salaries while securing the revenue’s interests.
- The court acknowledged the petitioner’s bona fide conduct and partial payment of dues.
- The directions included time-bound monetary deposits and lien over immovable assets.
- This case is a precedent on proportional use of provisional attachment powers under Section 83.
Summary of Referred Cases
| Name | Citation | Summary | Verdict |
| No case laws were expressly cited or discussed in the judgement | — | — | — |




