Home Case Laws Assessment Order Invalid Without Signature and DIN: Andhra Pradesh High Court

Assessment Order Invalid Without Signature and DIN: Andhra Pradesh High Court

0
282

Case Title: Bojja Upendra v. Assistant Commissioner ST, Nellore & Others
Court: High Court of Andhra Pradesh, Amaravati
Petition Number: Writ Petition No. 11586 of 2025
Date of Judgment: 30.04.2025
Coram: Justice R. Raghunandan Rao & Dr. Justice Y. Lakshmana Rao
Category of Dispute: Validity of Assessment Order – GST (Procedural Defect)
Relevant Sections: Sections 160 & 169 of CGST Act, 2017; CBIC Circular No.128/47/2019-GST dated 23.12.2019
Judgment: Assessment order and bank attachment set aside; liberty to issue fresh assessment with proper signature and DIN.


Facts of the Case

  • The petitioner was issued an assessment order in Form GST DRC-07 dated 01.10.2024 for FY 2022–23 by the 1st respondent [Para 1].

  • The order was challenged on grounds that it did not bear the signature of the Assessing Officer and lacked a Document Identification Number (DIN) [Para 2].

  • The petitioner’s bank account was also attached for recovery [Para 2].

  • The Government Pleader admitted the absence of both signature and DIN [Para 3].


Questions in Consideration

  1. Whether an assessment order issued without the signature of the assessing officer is valid under GST law? [Para 4].

  2. Whether absence of a DIN number renders the order invalid and unenforceable? [Para 6–7].


Observations of the Court

  • Earlier AP High Court rulings (A.V. Bhanoji Row v. AC ST; M/s. SRK Enterprises; M/s. SRS Traders) held that signature on assessment order is mandatory and cannot be dispensed with [Paras 4–5].

  • Supreme Court in Pradeep Goyal v. Union of India held that orders without DIN are non-est and invalid [Para 6].

  • Division Benches of AP High Court in Cluster Enterprises and Sai Manikanta Electrical Contractors confirmed that absence of DIN vitiates the proceedings [Para 7].

  • Therefore, the impugned order, lacking both signature and DIN, is invalid in law [Para 8].


Judgment of the Court

  • The assessment order dated 01.10.2024 in Form GST DRC-07 and the bank attachment order were set aside [Para 9].

  • Liberty was granted to the department to issue a fresh assessment order after due notice, with a valid signature and DIN [Para 9].

  • Time spent during pendency of this case shall be excluded from limitation computation [Para 9].

  • No order as to costs [Para 9].


Between Fine Lines (5-line Simplification)

  1. The GST assessment order issued to the petitioner lacked signature and DIN.

  2. Courts earlier ruled both are mandatory requirements.

  3. Supreme Court confirmed orders without DIN are invalid in law.

  4. High Court applied the same principle and quashed the order and bank attachment.

  5. Department may re-issue assessment with proper compliance.


Summary of Referred Cases

Case Name Citation Summary Verdict
A.V. Bhanoji Row v. AC (ST) W.P. No. 2830/2023 (AP HC) Held signature on assessment order is mandatory. Assessment order without signature invalid.
M/s. SRK Enterprises v. AC (ST) W.P. No. 29397/2023 (AP HC) Followed Bhanoji Row ruling. Order without signature quashed.
M/s. SRS Traders v. AC (ST) W.P. No. 5238/2024 (AP HC) Signature absence invalidates order. Assessment set aside.
Pradeep Goyal v. Union of India 2022 (63) G.S.T.L. 286 (SC) Supreme Court: Orders without DIN are non-est. Order invalid without DIN.
M/s. Cluster Enterprises v. Dy. AC (ST) 2024 (88) G.S.T.L. 179 (AP HC) Applied CBIC Circular – DIN mandatory. Order set aside.
Sai Manikanta Electrical Contractors v. Dy. Commissioner 2024 (88) G.S.T.L. 303 (AP HC) Absence of DIN vitiates order. Order quashed.

 

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY