Case Summary: M/s A.B. Traders v. Commissioner of Delhi Goods & Service Tax & Anr.
Court: High Court of Delhi
Petition No.: W.P.(C) 4739/2024 & CM APPL. 19450/2024
Date of Judgment: 02.04.2024
Relevant Sections: Sections 73, 75(3) of the CGST Act, 2017
Category: Adjudication – Validity of Assessment Order / Input Tax Credit / SCN Reply Not Considered
I. Facts of the Case (Paras 1–5)
The petitioner challenged the order dated 25.12.2023 whereby a demand of ₹44,48,488 was confirmed pursuant to a Show Cause Notice dated 26.09.2023. The adjudication was conducted under Section 73 of the CGST Act. The petitioner submitted a detailed reply on 23.10.2023 addressing all grounds—under-declaration of output tax, excess ITC, ITC reversals, and ITC from cancelled or defaulting dealers.
However, the adjudicating authority, while narrating submissions, concluded that the reply was “insufficient and unsatisfactory” without demonstrating any consideration of the explanations or supporting documents. The order merely repeated headings of the SCN issues and summarily rejected the petitioner’s defence.
II. Questions / Issues Before the Court (Paras 3–5)
-
Whether the adjudicating authority failed to consider the petitioner’s reply and the enclosed documentary evidence while confirming the demand under Section 73.
-
Whether a cryptic order that does not deal with each contention raised by the taxpayer violates principles of natural justice.
-
Whether the burden of establishing ITC admissibility was incorrectly shifted without examining evidence produced by the taxpayer.
III. Court’s Observations (Paras 3–6)
The Court observed that the SCN had raised multiple heads of alleged discrepancies, and the petitioner had furnished point-wise replies with disclosures. Nevertheless, the Proper Officer adopted a mechanistic approach and brushed aside the reply by merely stating that it was “insufficient”.
The Court noted that:
-
The order did not deal with any specific contention or documentary proof submitted by the taxpayer.
-
The adjudicating authority incorrectly relied on a generic proposition that the burden to prove ITC cannot be shifted to the tax authorities, without evaluating the petitioner’s documents.
-
The officer did not record why the transactions with the supplier were unacceptable nor did he provide any reasoning for rejecting the reply.
Thus, the adjudication violated the requirement of a reasoned and speaking order under Section 75(3) and offended principles of natural justice.
IV. Judgment / Final Directions (Paras 6–9)
The Court set aside the impugned order dated 25.12.2023 and remanded the matter to the Proper Officer for fresh adjudication on Points 1, 3, and 4 of the SCN.
Point 2 (Excess ITC), already decided in favour of the petitioner, was not remitted.
The petitioner was granted two weeks to furnish any further supporting documents. The Proper Officer must then:
-
Provide opportunity of personal hearing,
-
Consider all submissions and documents,
-
Pass a fresh, reasoned, speaking order within the statutory timeline under Section 75(3).
The Court clarified that it had not expressed any opinion on merits; all rights and contentions were left open.
V. Classification of the Case under GST Act (2017)
Statutory Classification:
-
Section 73 (Non-fraud demand adjudication)
-
Section 75(3) (Speaking order requirement)
-
Natural Justice in Adjudication
-
ITC Admissibility / SCN Compliance
Type: Assessment Order Set Aside for Non-consideration of Reply
VI. Summary of Cases Referred (with Verdicts)
Note: The judgment refers generally to legal principles but does not cite specific case names. Therefore, no individual precedents are listed in the order.
If you want, I can include relevant jurisprudence on “non-speaking orders”, ITC adjudication principles, burden of proof, etc., for publication purposes.
VII. Between Fine Lines – Practical Takeaways for Trade & Industry
This ruling reinforces that adjudicating officers cannot mechanically disregard taxpayer submissions. A reasoned adjudication must evaluate each contention with documentary evidence. Any order confirming demand without engaging with the reply is liable to be quashed. Taxpayers should ensure detailed, point-wise responses to SCNs and insist on a speaking order that demonstrates application of mind.
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”



