Home Case Laws Assessment orders set aside and remanded as High Court found lack of...

Assessment orders set aside and remanded as High Court found lack of application of mind and directed reconsideration after 10% deposit of disputed tax

0
329

Case Title: M/s. Tamil Selvi Enterprises v. The State Tax Officer & Anr.
Court: High Court of Judicature at Madras
Petition No.: W.P. Nos. 166 & 169 of 2025
Date of Judgment: 20.01.2025
Category: Assessment Order – Non-application of mind / Opportunity of Hearing
Relevant Sections: Sections 73 & 74 of the CGST Act, 2017; Article 226 of the Constitution of India

Facts (Para 2–4)

The petitioner, M/s. Tamil Selvi Enterprises, a registered civil works contractor under the GST Act, challenged assessment orders dated 24.08.2024 and 07.12.2024 for FY 2019-20 issued by the Villivakkam Assessment Circle. The orders alleged discrepancies between the petitioner’s GSTR-1, GSTR-3B, and GSTR-7 returns. The petitioner explained that part of the difference—₹3,17,473 out of ₹7,90,763—had already been paid in earlier proceedings dated 28.08.2024. The petitioner had also cleared other minor discrepancies.


Questions for Consideration (Para 3–5)

Whether the assessment orders suffered from non-application of mind and denial of adequate opportunity to present reconciliation before confirming the demand, especially when payments had already been made in respect of part of the disputed turnover?


Observations (Para 5–6)

The petitioner relied on Sree Manoj International v. Deputy State Tax Officer (W.P. No. 10977 of 2024, dated 25.04.2024), wherein the Court had remanded a similar matter subject to a pre-deposit of 10% of the disputed tax. The State did not object to adopting a similar course in the present case. The Court found that the impugned orders lacked consideration of payments already made and therefore warranted interference.


Judgment (Para 7)

The Court:

  1. Set aside the impugned assessment orders dated 24.08.2024 and 07.12.2024.

  2. Directed the petitioner to deposit 10% of the disputed tax within four weeks, after adjusting any amount already recovered or paid.

  3. Ordered that upon compliance, the impugned orders would be treated as show-cause notices, and the petitioner could file objections with supporting documents within four weeks.

  4. The assessing officer must pass a fresh order after affording a fair hearing.

  5. If the 10% payment or objections are not made within the stipulated time, the impugned orders will stand restored.

  6. Any bank attachment or garnishee proceedings to be withdrawn upon compliance.


Summary of Cases Referred

Case Name Citation Key Holding Relevance
Sree Manoj International v. Deputy State Tax Officer W.P. No. 10977 of 2024 (Madras HC, 25.04.2024) Matter remanded to assessing authority after directing 10% pre-deposit to ensure fair opportunity Used as precedent for remand with pre-deposit condition

Between Fine Lines

This ruling emphasizes that assessments based on return mismatches must be supported by due consideration of reconciliations and prior payments. Taxpayers should be granted reasonable opportunity before finalizing demands. The Madras High Court continues its consistent stance that procedural fairness and partial pre-deposit safeguards both revenue and trade interest.

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

 

LEAVE A REPLY