Twin Disc Power Transmission (P.) Ltd. v. Deputy Commissioner (ST), GST-Appeals
High Court of Madras | W.P. No. 26929 of 2021 | Category: Refund | Date of Judgement: 16-12-2021
Relevant Section: Section 54 of CGST Act, 2017; Rule 97A of CGST Rules, 2017
Facts of the Case
[Para 2] The petitioner, Twin Disc Power Transmission (P.) Ltd., is an exporter of services who had initially been granted refund for the month of July 2017. However, for subsequent refund claims (Aug 2017–Sept 2017 and Aug 2018–Jan 2019), the file was transferred to another officer who rejected the claims citing non-compliance with Section 2(6)(V) of the IGST Act.
[Para 3] Due to procedural issues and rejection in earlier claims, the petitioner could not upload refund applications for the period Feb 2019–Dec 2019, which later became time-barred under Section 54 of the CGST Act.
[Para 4] The petitioner then submitted a manual representation on 10-12-2021, seeking permission to file manual refund claims for that period.
Questions in Consideration
[Para 5] Whether the petitioner is entitled to file a manual refund application in light of Rule 97A of CGST Rules despite the system requiring electronic filing?
[Para 6] Whether such a manual application can be entertained after the limitation period prescribed under Section 54 of the CGST Act, owing to the procedural impediments?
Observation of Court
[Para 8] The Hon’ble Madras High Court took note of the Bombay High Court’s decision in Lakshmi Organic Industries Ltd. v. Union of India, which held that Rule 97A (non-obstante clause) permits manual filing where electronic filing is not feasible. The rule overrides procedural rigidity imposed by other rules (Rule 89–97).
[Para 9] It acknowledged that though the petitioner sought two alternative prayers, the issue regarding entitlement to manual refund filing is now settled in their favour prima facie.
Judgement of the Court
[Para 10] The Court disposed of the writ by directing the respondent authority to consider the petitioner’s representation dated 10-12-2021 in light of Lakshmi Organic Industries Ltd. judgment and take a decision within four weeks, without expressing an opinion on the merits. The petitioner’s right to challenge any adverse order was kept open.
Between Fine Lines (Summary in Simple Words)
- Exporter was earlier granted refund but later refund claims were rejected.
- Due to system issues, further applications could not be filed and became time-barred.
- Petitioner sought to file manual applications which was allowed based on Rule 97A.
- Madras HC directed department to consider manual claim per Bombay HC’s ruling.
- Case not finally adjudicated on refund entitlement, only allowed consideration of manual filing.
Summary of Referred Cases
| Name of Case | Citation | Summary | Verdict |
| Lakshmi Organic Industries Ltd. v. UOI | [2021] 133 taxmann.com 65 / [2022] 89 GST 463 (Bom.) | Held that Rule 97A allows manual refund application even where online portal mandates electronic filing. | Manual applications are valid; circulars cannot override statutory rules like Rule 97A. |
| F.S. Enterprise (referred in Lakshmi Organic) | (Citation not specified) | Officers are bound by CBIC instructions under Section 168 but cannot ignore statutory rules under Section 164. | Clarified that administrative instructions cannot override rules framed under parent statute. |
Takeaway
“Manual Filing vs. Portal Limitation: When Statutory Rule Overrides Procedure”




