Case Title: Roshni Sana Jaiswal v. Commissioner of Central Taxes GST Delhi (East)
Court: High Court of Delhi
Petition No.: W.P.(C) No. 2348 of 2021, CM No. 6860 of 2021
Date of Judgement: 12 May 2021
Category of Dispute: Provisional Attachment under Section 83
Relevant Sections: Section 83, Section 67, Section 2(107) of CGST Act, 2017; Rule 159(5) of CGST Rules, 2017
Facts of the Case:
- The petitioner, Ms. Roshni Sana Jaiswal, challenged the provisional attachment of her bank accounts dated 7.12.2020 by the GST authorities under Section 83 of the CGST Act, 2017. [Para 1]
- She had served as a Director of Milkfood Ltd. (2006–2008) and thereafter as a mentor/advisor, holding 14.33% equity and earning Rs. 1.5 crores in FY 2019–20. [Para 2.1–2.6]
- GST authorities initiated investigation under Section 67 against Milkfood Ltd. alleging availing of ITC based on fake invoices. [Para 2.2]
- The petitioner’s statement was recorded on 3.12.2020; she admitted her past role and current advisory engagement with Milkfood Ltd. [Para 2.4–2.5]
- The authorities provisionally attached her personal bank accounts, treating her as involved in the proceedings against Milkfood Ltd. [Para 2.7]
Question(s) in Consideration:
- Whether provisional attachment of the petitioner’s personal bank accounts under Section 83 of CGST Act was valid, despite her not being a “taxable person”? [Para 4]
- Whether the procedural requirements under Section 83 (existence of pending proceedings and necessity to protect revenue) were complied with? [Para 4.1]
Observation of the Court:
- The Court held that the petitioner was not a “taxable person” under Section 2(107) of the CGST Act, and hence her bank accounts could not have been attached under Section 83. [Para 5.3]
- The respondent failed to demonstrate that any pending proceeding under Sections 62, 63, 64, 67, 73, or 74 was against the petitioner or that attachment was necessary to protect revenue. [Para 5.5]
- No material was presented to show the petitioner’s involvement in the fake invoicing transactions; her statement did not indicate any culpability. [Para 5.6–5.7]
- The Court emphasized that attachment of bank accounts is a “draconian” measure and must be strictly within statutory confines. [Para 5.7]
Judgement of the Court:
- The writ petition was allowed; the impugned provisional attachment orders dated 7.12.2020 were quashed. [Para 6]
- The subsequent order dated 19.4.2021 rejecting her objections under Rule 159(5) also collapsed. [Para 6.1]
- Respondents were directed to communicate this order to the concerned banks for release of the attachments. [Para 6]
Between Fine Lines:
- A person not registered under GST cannot be treated as a “taxable person” for attachment of their property.
- Mere association with a company under investigation does not justify action under Section 83.
- Courts will intervene where jurisdictional excesses or procedural lapses occur despite alternate remedies.
- Draconian measures like bank attachment must be backed by concrete legal authority and necessity.
- Advisory roles and shareholding alone do not attract tax liability under GST laws.
Summary of Referred Cases:
| Case Name | Citation | Summary | Verdict/Application |
| Radha Krishan Industries v. State of Himachal Pradesh | [2021] 127 taxmann.com 26 | Held that Section 83 provisional attachment can only be invoked where proceedings under specific sections are pending and reasons are recorded | Petitioner relied on this case to show jurisdictional impropriety; Court found it applicable [Para 4.2, 5.1] |




