Case Title: M/s Marbaniang Projects Pvt. Ltd. v. Punjab National Bank & Ors.
Court: High Court of Meghalaya at Shillong
Petition No.: WP(C) No. 178 of 2022
Date of Judgement: 06.12.2024
Category of Dispute: GST Compliance – Statutory Liabilities vs. Debt Recovery
Relevant Provisions: Section 70, 37 of CGST Act, 2017; Rule 59(5)(a) of CGST Rules, 2017; Section 26-E SARFAESI Act, 2002; Section 31-B of RDDBFI Act, 1993
Facts of the Case (Paras 1–5, 14–17)
-
The petitioner company availed loans (₹22 crore + ₹8 crore) from Punjab National Bank for a hotel-cum-commercial project. An Escrow Agreement (20.02.2015) mandated that taxes and statutory dues (including GST) be paid first before debt repayment.
-
Despite this, since 2017 the Bank adjusted all escrow deposits towards loan repayment, ignoring statutory dues, resulting in non-payment of GST and inability to file GSTR-3B, thus blocking GSTR-1 filings (Rule 59(5)(a)).
-
Tenants withheld rent when ITC was not passed down. The company was declared NPA in 2019.
-
The petitioner argued that the Bank, which solely controlled the escrow account, violated the priority order, frustrating GST compliance.
Questions in Consideration (Para 12)
-
Maintainability: Whether writ is maintainable despite pending DRT proceedings.
-
Breach: Whether Bank’s adjustment of escrow deposits breached Escrow Agreement.
-
Control: Whether petitioner had any control or right to operate escrow account.
Observations of the Court
-
Maintainability (Paras 13–14): Writ petition filed in 2022, before DRT proceedings (2023). Issue is distinct (breach of escrow vs. recovery of debt). Petition maintainable.
-
Breach of Escrow Agreement (Paras 15–17): Agreement explicitly prioritised statutory dues over debt repayment. Bank’s adjustment to loans directly caused GST non-compliance and cascading financial difficulties. This was a clear breach.
-
Control over Escrow (Paras 18–19): Petitioner had no control; only Bank operated the escrow account. Hence, petitioner cannot be held solely responsible for statutory default.
-
Relief (Para 20): Since GST authorities were not made parties, Court limited relief to directing Bank to take corrective measures to enable petitioner to file GST returns (2017 onwards).
Judgement of the Court (Paras 20–21)
-
Petition allowed in part.
-
Bank held liable for breach of escrow agreement.
-
Directed to take corrective steps to facilitate petitioner’s GST return filings from 2017 onwards.
-
Full monetary relief (direct GST payments by Bank) not granted as GST Department was not impleaded.
Between Fine Lines (Simplified Outcome)
-
Bank wrongly used escrow funds for loan recovery instead of GST payments.
-
Court held Bank in breach of agreement; writ maintainable despite DRT case.
-
GST default arose from Bank’s actions, not petitioner’s fault alone.
-
Bank must assist in rectifying GST compliance from 2017 onwards.
-
Relief limited due to absence of GST Department as party.
Summary of Referred Cases
| Case Name | Citation | Summary | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| Employees Provident Fund Commissioner v. Official Liquidator of Esskay Pharmaceuticals Ltd. | (2011) 10 SCC 727 | Held statutory dues like taxes, cesses and wages have priority over debts | Supported petitioner’s claim of priority of GST |
| Paschimanchal Vidyut Vitran Nigam Ltd. v. Raman Ispat Pvt. Ltd. | (2023) 10 SCC 60 | Held secured creditors have priority over govt. dues post statutory amendments | Relied by Bank to deny GST priority |
| ICICI Bank Ltd. v. Sidco Leathers Ltd. | (2006) 10 SCC 452 | Priority of secured creditors over govt. dues reaffirmed | Relied by Bank |
| Andhra Bank v. Official Liquidator | (2005) 5 SCC 75 | Secured creditors’ claims superior to government dues | Relied by Bank |
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”




