Case Reference:
Sri Beeragondanahalli Halagappa Somashekarappa v. State of Karnataka & Ors.
High Court of Karnataka, Bengaluru
W.P. No. 12345 of 2024 (T-RES)
Judgment dated: 03 July 2025
Relevant Section: Section 62 & Section 161 of the KGST Act, 2017
Category: Return filing delay and Best Judgment Assessment
Facts (Paras 2–5):
The petitioner, a civil contractor, failed to file GSTR-3B returns for March, April, and May 2023. Consequently, best judgment assessments under Section 62 of the KGST Act were passed by the Assistant Commissioner for those months. The petitioner later filed the returns between August and October 2023. He argued that financial hardship and lack of business led to the delay.
He filed appeals under Section 107(1), which were dismissed. Later, relying on the Madras High Court decision in Helmet House v. Deputy State Tax Officer-1, Madurai (2024) 167 Taxmann.com 81, he contended that the Finance Act, 2023 amendment to Section 62 (effective 01.10.2023) allowing 120 days to file valid returns should apply to his case.
Question of Law (Para 10):
Whether returns filed belatedly before the amendment date could be accepted by applying the beneficial amendment to Section 62 introduced by the Finance Act, 2023, effective 01.10.2023?
Observations (Paras 11–13):
The Court noted that the Madras High Court in Helmet House treated the amendment as beneficial, meant to give taxpayers more time to file returns and regularize assessments. Justice Suraj Govindaraj held that such an interpretation aligns with the legislative intent of enabling compliance rather than penalizing delay.
It was observed that although the amendment is prospective, its beneficial nature warranted application in the petitioner’s case since he had already filed the returns within 120 days from the assessment orders.
Accordingly, the first 60 days attract no late fee, while the subsequent 60 days attract ₹ 100 per day as late fee under the amended provision.
Judgment (Para 14):
-
The writ petition was allowed.
-
The Department was directed to accept the belated GSTR-3B returns for March–May 2023.
-
The original best judgment orders under Section 62 were withdrawn upon such acceptance.
-
The matter was remitted to the Assistant Commissioner to compute the late fee within 15 days.
-
The petitioner was ordered to pay the late fee within 30 days thereafter.
Summary of Referred Case:
| Case | Court | Key Issue | Decision | Relevance |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Helmet House v. Deputy State Tax Officer-1, Madurai (2024) 167 Taxmann.com 81 | Madras High Court | Applicability of amended Section 62 allowing 120 days for return filing | Held that amendment is beneficial and remedial, thus available to taxpayers to regularize returns filed belatedly | Cited to extend the same benefit to petitioner in this case |
Between Fine Lines:
The Karnataka High Court reaffirmed that GST law aims to encourage compliance rather than punish delay. By applying the beneficial amendment to Section 62, the Court allowed taxpayers who missed return deadlines to file within 120 days and regularize their position by paying prescribed late fees. This decision eases hardships for small contractors and others who inadvertently delay return filings.
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”




