Home Case Laws Blocking of ITC and GST Demand – Writ Petition Dismissed

Blocking of ITC and GST Demand – Writ Petition Dismissed

0
245

Case Details

  • Case Title: M/s. Malabar Trading Co. v. State Tax Officer & Others

  • Court: High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam

  • Petition Number: WP(C) No. 33750 of 2024

  • Date of Judgment: 12 December 2024

  • Category of Dispute: Input Tax Credit (ITC) Blockage & Demand under Section 74

  • Relevant Provisions:

    • Section 16, 74, 75(4), 107 of CGST/SGST Act, 2017

    • Rule 86A(1) of CGST/SGST Rules, 2017


Facts of the Case (Ref: ¶2–4)

  1. Petitioner, a registered dealer engaged in trading scraps, was alleged to have availed fraudulent ITC through transactions with M/s. Modern Enterprises using fake invoices without actual supply of goods. (¶2)

  2. Department issued order under Rule 86A(1) blocking ITC worth ₹8,88,010/- in electronic credit ledger and passed adjudication order under Section 74 imposing tax, interest, and penalty aggregating to ₹20,05,298/-. (¶2)

  3. Petitioner contended that purchases were genuine, consideration was paid, and all conditions under Section 16 were satisfied. It alleged violation of natural justice as no effective hearing was granted before passing the impugned orders. (¶3)

  4. Revenue argued that opportunity of hearing was provided (Advocate appeared), and remedy lies in appeal under Section 107; hence writ is not maintainable. (¶4)


Questions for Consideration

  1. Whether the orders under Rule 86A (blocking ITC) and Section 74 (demand, penalty) were passed without granting effective hearing in violation of Section 75(4)? (¶6)

  2. Whether writ jurisdiction under Article 226 can be invoked against ITC blockage and adjudication order when alternate statutory remedy of appeal is available? (¶9–10)


Observations of the Court (¶6–9)

  1. Exhibit P7 order records appearance of petitioner’s counsel and explanation of objections; hence plea of denial of hearing involves disputed facts that cannot be decided under Article 226. (¶6)

  2. ITC blockage under Rule 86A(1) is valid only for one year (expired on date of judgment); law does not mandate pre-decisional hearing for such action. (¶7)

  3. Petitioner has an effective statutory appeal remedy under Section 107 against adjudication order. (¶9)

  4. Allegations of fake invoices and fraudulent transactions are factual disputes which cannot be examined in writ proceedings. (¶9–10)

  5. Cited judgments (Parity Infotech – Delhi HC; Balaji Electricals – Madras HC) were held factually distinguishable. (¶8)


Judgment of the Court (¶10–11)

  • Writ petition dismissed. (¶10–11)

  • Court directed exclusion of time spent in writ proceedings (25.09.2024 to 12.12.2024) while computing limitation for filing appeal under Section 107. (¶11)


Between Fine Lines

  • ITC blockage under Rule 86A is temporary (1 year) and does not require hearing.

  • Denial of hearing allegations cannot be tested in writ if disputed facts exist.

  • Remedy against Section 74 adjudication lies in appeal under Section 107.

  • Writ jurisdiction under Article 226 will not be exercised where alternate remedies exist.

  • Time spent in writ can be excluded for appeal limitation benefit.


Summary of Referred Cases

Case Name Citation Summary Verdict
M/s. Parity Infotech Solutions Pvt. Ltd. v. Govt. of NCT of Delhi 2023 (75) G.S.T.L. 329 (Del.) Concerned challenge to ITC blocking without due procedure Held distinguishable; not applicable to present facts
M/s. Balaji Electrical & Hardwares v. State Tax Officer 2024 (83) G.S.T.L. 114 (Mad.) Challenge to arbitrary ITC blocking Held distinguishable; not applicable to present case

 

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY