Case Title: M/s Sadhana Enviro Engineering Services v. Union of India & Others
Court: High Court of Karnataka, Bengaluru
Petition Number: Writ Petition No. 6138 of 2020 (T-RES)
Category of Dispute: Input Tax Credit
Date of Judgment: 03 September 2024
Relevant Sections: Section 16(4), 16(5), 39, 164(3) CGST Act; Rule 61(5), Rule 86A CGST Rules
Presiding Judge: Hon’ble Mr. Justice S.R. Krishna Kumar
Facts of the Case (¶1–3)
-
The petitioner, M/s Sadhana Enviro Engineering Services, challenged the constitutional validity of several provisions, including Section 16(4), Rule 86A, and blocking of ITC ledger (¶1).
-
The petitioner’s ITC claim of ₹33,78,077 was blocked via order dated 03.02.2020 (Annexure-F) (¶1, ¶3).
-
During pendency, a legislative amendment via Finance (No.2) Act, 2024 inserted Section 16(5) to CGST Act, enabling ITC claims for FY 2017–18 to 2020–21 till 30.11.2021 (¶3).
Questions in Consideration (¶1, ¶3, ¶5)
-
Whether the petitioner is entitled to ITC benefit in light of the newly inserted Section 16(5)?
-
Whether the blocking of the petitioner’s ITC ledger is sustainable?
-
Whether other provisions impugned by the petitioner (like Section 16(4), Rule 86A, etc.) are unconstitutional?
Observations of the Court (¶5–6)
-
The Court noted that Section 16(5) overrides Section 16(4) and provides extended ITC claim timelines up to 30.11.2021 for the specified financial years (¶5).
-
Both parties agreed that the newly inserted Section 16(5) applies to the petitioner (¶4–5).
-
The Court found that the blocking of ITC was unsustainable in light of the new statutory provision (¶6).
Judgment of the Court (¶7)
-
The writ petition was disposed of, and parties relegated to the stage of the original SCN dated 13.02.2020 (¶7(i)–(ii)).
-
The blocking of ITC via order dated 03.02.2020 (Annexure-F) was quashed (¶7(iii)).
-
The Respondents were directed to immediately unblock the ITC ledger balance of ₹33,78,077 (¶7(iv)).
-
All other constitutional and legal challenges raised by the petitioner were left open for future adjudication (¶7(v)).
Between Fine Lines
-
ITC claims blocked under old timelines now allowed under Section 16(5).
-
Blocking order of ₹33.78 lakhs quashed.
-
Petitioner to get opportunity to present case afresh.
-
Refund/credit processing must align with the 2024 amendment.
-
Other legal contentions remain undecided for future litigation.
Summary of Referred Cases
| Name | Citation | Summary | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| None explicitly cited in the judgment | — | The decision relied on mutual admissions about legislative amendment rather than past judicial precedents | Not Applicable |
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”




