Home Updates Bombay High Court: Mere Delay in Paying Tax Does Not Establish Wilful...

Bombay High Court: Mere Delay in Paying Tax Does Not Establish Wilful Evasion under Section 276C(2)

0
101

Case: Dinar Tarcar Resources (India) Pvt. Ltd. represented by Shri Ankush Pednekar and 2 Others v. The Income Tax Department represented by the Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax

Court: High Court of Bombay at Goa

Coram: Justice Amit S. Jamsandekar

Case No.: Criminal Writ Petition No. 202 of 2026

Neutral Citation: 2026:BHC-GOA:1484

Date of Judgment: 28 July 2026

Background of the Case

The Bombay High Court at Goa considered a challenge to criminal proceedings initiated against Dinar Tarcar Resources (India) Pvt. Ltd., its Managing Director and its Joint Managing Director under Section 276C(2) of the Income-tax Act, 1961.

The prosecution alleged that the company had wilfully attempted to evade payment of its admitted tax liability for Assessment Year 2012-13. On the basis of the complaint filed by the Income Tax Department, the Chief Judicial Magistrate, ‘A’ Court at Merces, issued process against the petitioners by an order dated 7 November 2025.

The petitioners challenged both the complaint and the order issuing process before the High Court.

Facts Considered by the High Court

The company had filed its return of income under Section 139 and declared an income of ₹4,76,61,800 for Assessment Year 2012-13. The declared income was accepted by the Department in the assessment order dated 15 March 2016.

According to the petitioners, the delay in payment arose because the company’s iron ore trading and export business had been severely affected by the suspension of mining operations in Goa. The company repeatedly communicated its financial difficulties to the Department, sought time for payment and continued to make payments towards the outstanding liability.

The Principal Commissioner of Income Tax granted sanction for prosecution on 30 January 2017 under Section 279(1). The Department thereafter filed the criminal complaint on 10 March 2017.

The record showed that the company made substantial payments before and after the sanction for prosecution. Out of the total liability of ₹5,20,90,289, only ₹26,08,047 remained unpaid when the complaint was filed. This balance was paid on 20 March 2017.

On 29 March 2017, the Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax passed an order under Section 154 recording the net payable amount as nil.

Issue Before the Court

The principal issue was whether a delay or failure in paying admitted tax, by itself, amounted to a “wilful attempt” to evade payment of tax, penalty or interest so as to attract prosecution under Section 276C(2) of the Income-tax Act.

The Court also examined whether the complaint contained specific allegations establishing the essential ingredients of the offence and whether the Magistrate had properly applied his mind before issuing process.

High Court’s Interpretation of “Wilful Attempt”

The High Court noted that Section 276C(2) does not punish every delay, failure or default in paying tax. The provision applies only when a person wilfully attempts to evade payment of tax, penalty or interest.

The word “wilful” introduces a mental element into the offence. It denotes conduct that is deliberate, intentional and conscious. The conduct must demonstrate an intention to evade payment.

The Court explained that a genuine inability to pay, an accidental or casual omission, or a mere delay without the necessary guilty intention would not satisfy the statutory requirement.

Accordingly, mens rea is an essential ingredient of prosecution under Section 276C(2). A complaint must disclose the specific acts constituting the alleged wilful attempt. A general or vague allegation that the accused attempted to evade tax is not sufficient.

Mere Default Is Different from Wilful Attempt

The Court drew an important distinction between a “wilful attempt” and a “wilful default”.

Section 276C(2) uses the expression “wilful attempt”. Therefore, the prosecution must establish not only a failure to pay but also some deliberate act or conduct intended to evade payment.

The explanation to Section 276C identifies conduct such as maintaining false entries, making false statements, deliberately omitting relevant entries or creating circumstances that enable tax evasion. Although the explanation is inclusive, every prosecution must still satisfy the essential requirement of wilfulness.

The Court held that penal provisions cannot be invoked merely because payment was delayed. All ingredients of the alleged offence must be apparent from the complaint itself.

Conduct of the Taxpayer Was Bona Fide

The High Court found that the company had continuously communicated with the Department, sought time, explained its financial difficulties and periodically paid the tax liability along with applicable interest.

The company had not concealed its income or understated its tax liability. The income declared in the return had been accepted by the Department.

The taxpayer’s conduct, including the continued payment of tax and interest and the eventual clearance of the entire demand, was inconsistent with an intention to evade payment.

The subsequent order recording nil outstanding liability further supported the conclusion that no deliberate attempt to evade payment had been established.

Magistrate’s Order Was Mechanical

The Court reiterated that summoning an accused in a criminal prosecution is a serious matter. A Magistrate is required to examine the allegations, supporting material and applicable law before issuing process.

In the present case, the Chief Judicial Magistrate failed to consider material facts, including the payments made by the company and the order recording nil outstanding liability.

The complaint did not identify any specific deliberate act by which the petitioners attempted to evade tax. The High Court therefore held that the order issuing process had been passed mechanically and without proper application of mind.

Decision of the Bombay High Court

The Bombay High Court held that the complaint did not disclose the essential ingredients of an offence under Section 276C(2).

The Court found that:

The company had declared the correct income and tax liability.

The delay in payment arose from financial and business difficulties.

The company continuously made payments and paid interest on delayed payment.

Almost the entire liability had been discharged before the complaint was filed.

The remaining amount was paid shortly thereafter.

The Department subsequently recorded the net payable amount as nil.

The complaint contained no specific allegation establishing a deliberate or conscious attempt to evade payment.

Accordingly, the Court quashed the order dated 7 November 2025 issuing process, as well as Criminal Case No. AOA/184/2017/A pending before the Chief Judicial Magistrate, ‘A’ Court at Merces.

The writ petition was allowed and the rule was made absolute, with no order as to costs.

Legal Principle Emerging from the Judgment

For prosecution under Section 276C(2), the Income Tax Department must establish a deliberate, intentional and conscious attempt to evade payment of tax, penalty or interest.

Mere non-payment, delayed payment or financial inability does not automatically constitute a criminal offence. The complaint must contain specific factual allegations showing mens rea and conduct directed towards evasion.

The judgment also reinforces that a criminal court must independently examine whether the statutory ingredients of the offence are disclosed before summoning the accused.

Significance of the Ruling

The ruling is significant for companies, directors and taxpayers facing prosecution for delayed payment of admitted tax liabilities.

It clarifies that criminal prosecution cannot be used as an automatic consequence of every tax default. The distinction between civil recovery consequences and penal liability must be maintained.

The judgment is particularly relevant where the taxpayer has disclosed the correct income, acknowledged the liability, communicated genuine financial difficulties and made substantial or complete payment together with interest.

Conclusion

The Bombay High Court has reaffirmed that criminal liability under Section 276C(2) depends upon proof of a wilful attempt to evade payment and not merely upon the existence of delayed tax dues.

Where the taxpayer’s conduct demonstrates bona fide efforts to discharge the liability and the complaint contains only vague allegations without establishing mens rea, continuation of criminal prosecution would amount to an abuse of the process of law.

Download

LEAVE A REPLY