Home Updates Calcutta High Court Quashes Ex Parte GST Order for Improper Portal Communication

Calcutta High Court Quashes Ex Parte GST Order for Improper Portal Communication

0
93

The Calcutta High Court, in M/s. B. Enterprise & Anr. v. The State of West Bengal & Ors., examined whether an ex parte adjudication order passed under Section 73(1) of the WBGST/CGST Act, 2017 could be sustained when the statutory notices and adjudication order were uploaded only under the “Additional Notices and Orders” tab of the GST portal.

The petitioners challenged the adjudication order dated 20 August 2024 passed by the Assistant Commissioner of Revenue, Siliguri Charge. According to the petitioners, the pre-show-cause notice, show-cause notices, reminder communications and adjudication order were never made available under the regular “Notices/Orders” tab. They were instead uploaded under the “Additional Notices and Orders” tab, due to which the petitioners claimed that they remained unaware of the proceedings until 5 March 2026.

The Court observed that it is judicially settled that merely placing notices and adjudication orders under the “Additional Notices and Orders” tab cannot be treated as valid communication for proceedings under Section 73(1) of the GST law. Since the petitioners were not effectively informed of the proceedings, they could not submit a reply or participate in the adjudication process.

The High Court also noticed a further procedural defect. The show-cause notice dated 14 May 2024 and the reminder dated 24 July 2024 indicated that the date of personal hearing had been fixed before the expiry of the period allowed for submitting a reply. The Court held that such scheduling demonstrated that the petitioners had not been granted an effective opportunity to defend themselves.

Accordingly, the Court concluded that the principles of natural justice had been grossly violated. The petitioners could not be blamed for failing to respond to the show-cause notice or for not participating in the adjudication proceedings.

The Court further clarified that the dismissal of an appeal as time-barred did not affect the maintainability of the writ petition. The appeal had not been filed against the ex parte adjudication order dated 20 August 2024 but against a separate intimation in Form DRC-OIA dated 3 March 2024.

The Calcutta High Court therefore set aside and quashed the adjudication order dated 20 August 2024. The petitioners were granted liberty to submit their reply to the show-cause notice within fourteen working days from receipt of the server copy of the judgment.

The Assistant Commissioner of State Tax, Siliguri Charge, was directed to reconsider the matter afresh after granting an opportunity of personal hearing and to pass a reasoned order as expeditiously as possible. The petitioners were also permitted to raise the issue of amounts already deposited, which the adjudicating authority was directed to consider while deciding the matter.

Importantly, the Court clarified that the adjudication order was interfered with only on the ground of violation of natural justice. All substantive issues arising from the show-cause notice were left open for fresh determination by the adjudicating authority.

The ruling reinforces that uploading GST notices in an inappropriate or less visible section of the portal may not amount to effective statutory communication. It also reiterates that taxpayers must receive a meaningful opportunity to reply and be heard before an adverse adjudication order is passed.

 

Download

LEAVE A REPLY