1. Title of the Document
| Document Title | Clarification on issues related to demand, adjudication and appeal proceedings under the CGST Act, 2017 |
| Document Number | Circular No. 258/04/2026-GST (F. No. CBIC-20001/2/2026-GST) |
| Issuing Authority | Central Board of Indirect Taxes & Customs (CBIC), GST Policy Wing, Department of Revenue, Ministry of Finance, Government of India |
| Date of Document | 26.10.2026 |
| Relevant Provisions | CGST Act, 2017: sections 5(2), 6, 73, 74, 74A, 75(4), 75(5), 75(7), 75(9), 107, 116, 126, 161, 168(1) and 169. CGST Rules, 2017: rules 100, 108, 109C, 112, 113 and 142 (including 142(1A) and 142(5)); FORMS GST DRC-01A, DRC-01, DRC-02, DRC-06, DRC-07, DRC-08, APL-01/03W, APL-02 and APL-04. |
2. Summary of the Document
The Central Board of Indirect Taxes and Customs has issued Circular No. 258/04/2026-GST dated 26.10.2026 under section 168(1) of the CGST Act, 2017, to give officers a uniform reference framework for demand, adjudication and appeal proceedings. The Circular records that orders have, at times, been vague, non-speaking or silent on the taxpayer’s submissions, leading to avoidable remand and litigation. It encourages, wherever feasible, a pre-show cause notice intimation in Part A of FORM GST DRC-01A under rule 142(1A) before action under section 73, 74 or 74A.
On show cause notices, the Circular states that a notice should set out the noticee’s particulars, factual background, provisions allegedly contravened, statement of charges, a quantified demand (financial year-wise where possible), the Adjudicating Authority and the reply deadline. Relying on the Telangana High Court in Nice Enterprises and the Supreme Court in G.R. Infra Project Ltd. (19.08.2026), it stresses that deficiencies in a notice cannot be cured later. Demands under sections 73 and 74 must be separately quantified with reasons, parallel proceedings barred by section 6 are to be avoided, and summaries must be issued in FORM GST DRC-01 and DRC-02.
Extended-period demands under section 74(1) or 74A(5)(ii) require specific material, disclosed in the notice itself, showing fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression with intent to evade tax. Mere non-payment, or a discrepancy found in scrutiny, does not suffice, and a second notice on the same facts and grounds is generally not valid. Where such material is absent, the order should record findings and confine the demand to section 73 or section 74A(5)(i).
On hearings and orders, the Circular operationalises section 75(4) and 75(5): up to four hearings, reasons for declining adjournments, virtual hearings, recorded proceedings, a fresh hearing after the officer’s transfer, and an order preferably within one month. The order must be a speaking order that examines evidence critically, deals with every defence and case law cited, stays within the notice as required by section 75(7), quantifies tax, interest and penalty issue-wise and justifies penalty with reference to section 126. Artificial Intelligence tools may be used only with human oversight.
Rectification under section 161 is limited to errors apparent on the face of the record, must be made by the issuing authority itself through FORM GST DRC-08, and is no substitute for appeal. In first appeals under section 107, limitation is to be decided as a separate preliminary issue, hearing details recorded in the order, reasons given on additional grounds and additional evidence under rule 112, cross-appeals disposed of together, and the summary issued in FORM GST APL-04.
Legal Takeaway: Paragraph 17 states that these guidelines are illustrative and are not to be cited by officers in notices or orders, yet they give taxpayers a ready benchmark. Replies and appeals under sections 73, 74, 74A, 75 and 107 may rely on the Circular’s expectations, alongside the case law it cites, to challenge non-speaking orders, mechanical allegations of suppression, demands beyond the notice and denial of hearing.
Disclaimer: Prepared by Team GSTIndiaguide.com. This summary is for information and does not constitute legal advice. Refer to original notification, judgement, circular or other documents for reference.
3. Tabular Summary
| Sl. No. | Para No. | Topic | Provision(s) / Authority | Guideline / Clarification | Authority Concerned | Form / Procedure | Practical Implication for Taxpayer |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Para 2 | Pre-SCN intimation | Sec. 73, 74, 74A; Rule 142(1A) | Wherever feasible, tax assessed as payable may be intimated before SCN, giving taxpayer a chance to clarify. | Proper officer | Part A of FORM GST DRC-01A | Respond to DRC-01A; clarify or pay before SCN is issued. |
| 2 | Paras 3-3.2 | Show cause notice and summary | Rules 100 and 142 | SCN is the foundational document; summary to accompany notice or statement electronically. | Proper officer | FORM GST DRC-01 / DRC-02 | Check that the summary is uploaded on the portal with the notice. |
| 3 | Paras 4-4.6 | Structure and drafting of SCN | Natural justice; Nice Enterprises (Telangana HC); G.R. Infra (SC) | Profile, facts, legal framework, charges, quantified demand, authority and reply deadline; deficiencies cannot be cured later. | Proper officer | SCN | Vague or bare-text notices can be challenged on natural-justice grounds. |
| 4 | Paras 5-5.5 | Fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression | Sec. 74(1), 74A(5)(ii), Expl. 2 to 74A; G.R. Infra; Sriba Nirman | Notice must disclose specific material showing intent to evade tax; not for mere discrepancy; repeat SCN on same facts generally invalid. | Proper officer | SCN | Insist on particulars of intent; object to mechanical invocation of extended grounds. |
| 5 | Para 6 | Notices covering sections 73 and 74 / 74A | Sec. 73, 74, 74A | Reasons for bifurcation and separate quantification; single 42-month period under section 74A from FY 2024-25. | Proper officer | SCN | Check that each demand is separately quantified and grounded. |
| 6 | Para 7 | No parallel proceedings | Sec. 6; Armour Security (SC), para 97 | No CGST proceedings on subject matter already initiated under SGST/UTGST; coordination required. | CGST and SGST officers | Coordination | Raise objection where the same subject matter is pursued by two authorities. |
| 7 | Paras 8-9 | Timely issuance and service of SCN | Sec. 73(10), 73(2), 74(10), 74(2), 74A(7), 74A(2), 169; Rule 142 | Notices to be issued well before the due date; service by modes in section 169. | Proper officer | FORM GST DRC-01 | Verify limitation and mode of service. |
| 8 | Paras 10-10.1 | Natural justice and personal hearing | Sec. 75(4), 75(5), 116 | Maximum four hearings; reasoned refusal of adjournment; virtual hearing; recorded hearings; fresh hearing on transfer; order preferably within one month. | Adjudicating Authority | Personal hearing | Request hearing in writing; appoint authorised representative; keep proof of hearings. |
| 9 | Paras 11-11.11 | Adjudication order | Sec. 75(7), 75(9), 126; Rules 100 and 142; Saheli Leasing (SC) | Speaking order; critical examination of evidence and submissions; case laws discussed; issue-wise quantification; reasoned penalty. | Adjudicating Authority | FORM GST DRC-07 | Non-speaking orders or findings beyond the notice may be challenged in appeal. |
| 10 | Para 12 | Timely adjudication | Rule 142(5) | Avoid last-minute orders; monthly disposal targets; summary in DRC-07. | Adjudicating Authority / senior officers | FORM GST DRC-07 | Check whether the order is time-barred and summary uploaded. |
| 11 | Para 13 | Determination of extended-period demand | Sec. 73, 74A(5)(i) | Absent evidence of intent, demand to be confined to section 73 or 74A(5)(i), with reasons for rejecting submissions. | Adjudicating Authority | Adjudication order | Specifically contest extended period in the reply. |
| 12 | Paras 14-14.2.3 | Rectification of errors | Sec. 161; Arun Dev Upadhyaya (SC) | Only errors apparent on the face of the record; by issuing authority itself; no review of merits. | Issuing authority | FORM GST DRC-08 | Apply within three months; use appeal for errors of law or fact. |
| 13 | Paras 15-15.1 | First appeal and preliminary scrutiny | Sec. 107; Rules 108 and 113 | Scrutiny of maintainability; merits not to be rejected summarily at registration. | First Appellate Authority | FORM GST APL-04 | Ensure completeness of appeal, pre-deposit and documents. |
| 14 | Paras 15.2-15.3 | Limitation and withdrawal | Sec. 107(1), 107(4); Rule 109C | Limitation examined first; non-condonable delay not decided on merits; withdrawal subject to approval after APL-02. | First Appellate Authority | FORM GST APL-01/03W, APL-02 | File within three months, or one more month with sufficient cause. |
| 15 | Paras 15.4-15.8 | Hearings, additional grounds and evidence, disposal | Sec. 107(10), 107(11), 107(13); Rule 112 | Hearing details in order; reasons on additional grounds and evidence; one-year target; common order for cross-appeals. | First Appellate Authority | FORM GST APL-04 | Seek admission of additional evidence under rule 112 with sufficient cause. |
| 16 | Paras 16-18 | Application to appeals; nature of guidelines | Sec. 168(1) | Paras 10, 11 and 13 apply mutatis mutandis to appeals; guidelines illustrative and not to be cited by officers. | CBIC / field formations | Circular | Use as a benchmark; difficulties may be brought to the Board’s notice. |
Download the Document: Circular No. 258/04/2026-GST dated 26.10.2026 (CBIC)




