Home Case Laws Challenge to GST penalty notices dismissed as High Court held jurisdictional objections...

Challenge to GST penalty notices dismissed as High Court held jurisdictional objections could be raised before adjudicating authority and writ not maintainable at SCN stage

0
305

Case: S. Kushalchand International Pvt. Ltd. & Anr. v. The Additional Director, DGGI & Anr.

Court: High Court of Gujarat, Ahmedabad
Petition No.: R/Special Civil Application Nos. 15904, 15906 & 15924 of 2023
Judgment Date: 23.01.2025 (Reserved on 18.10.2024)
Relevant Sections: Sections 122(1), 122(1A), 122(3), 74 of CGST Act, 2017; Notifications No. 02/2017, 02/2022; Circulars No. 31/2018 & 169/2022
Category of Dispute: Penalty – Jurisdiction of Proper Officer

Facts (Paras 1–15, 25–33)

The petitioner company, engaged in chemical imports and trading, was issued three show cause notices dated 16.03.2022 alleging supply of raw materials to entities (Flora Naturale, Odochem Industries, Odosynth Inc.) engaged in clandestine perfumery compound production used in pan masala and scented tobacco. Investigations revealed stock shortages, unrecorded cash freight payments to transporters, and alleged complicity in GST evasion. Notices proposed penalty under Section 122(1) and 122(1A) of CGST Act. Petitioners contended that the Additional/Joint Commissioner, CGST Kanpur lacked jurisdiction, and penalty provisions were wrongly invoked.


Questions before Court (Paras 13–24, 75–77)

  1. Whether the adjudication by Additional/Joint Commissioner, Kanpur was without jurisdiction given notifications and circulars?

  2. Whether penalty under Sections 122(1) or 122(1A) could be imposed when no demand was raised against the petitioner under Sections 73/74?

  3. Whether the writ petition under Article 226 was maintainable at show cause notice stage?


Observations (Paras 80–88)

  • The Court noted that SCNs were issued by DGGI Ahmedabad, but the main noticees were situated in Kannauj, Uttar Pradesh, falling within Kanpur Commissionerate. Hence, Kanpur Commissionerate officers had jurisdiction.

  • Reliance on Notification 02/2017, Circular 31/2018 and Circular 169/2022 was misplaced as they only clarified distribution of adjudication powers, not exclusion of Kanpur Commissionerate.

  • The Allahabad High Court had earlier dismissed similar writ petitions by co-noticees, holding no inherent lack of jurisdiction.

  • Jurisdictional and penalty applicability issues were questions for adjudication, not for writ interference.


Judgment (Paras 87–94)

The High Court dismissed the petitions, holding that:

  • Writ jurisdiction under Article 226 cannot be invoked at SCN stage unless notices are ex facie without jurisdiction, which was not the case.

  • Petitioners can raise all objections, including jurisdictional and penalty-related grounds, before the adjudicating authority.

  • Extraordinary jurisdiction is not to be exercised when disputed questions of fact and statutory remedies exist.

  • Interim relief against passing final order was also refused.

Held: Petitions dismissed, leaving all issues open for adjudication.


Case References

Case Referred Court Ratio
Trimurti Fragrances Pvt Ltd v. DGGI (2023) Allahabad HC Writs against SCN not maintainable; no lack of jurisdiction
Union of India v. Coastal Container Transporters (2019) SC Writ against SCN not maintainable unless jurisdictional defect
Siemens Ltd. v. State of Maharashtra (2006) SC Writ against SCN should not be entertained unless without jurisdiction
Special Director v. Mohd. Ghulam Ghouse (2004) SC High Courts should avoid stalling SCN enquiries
CIT v. Vatika Township (2015) SC Amendments creating substantive liability operate prospectively
Shantanu Sanjay Hundekari v. UOI (2024) Bombay HC Beneficiary liability under Section 122(1A) questioned
Sakshi Bahl v. DGGI (2023) Delhi HC SCN jurisdiction examined
Veremax Technologie Services Ltd. v. ACCT (2024) Karnataka HC SCN jurisdictional challenge dismissed
Titan Company Ltd. v. JC GST (2024) Madras HC Adjudication should proceed; writ not maintainable
Kesar Enterprises Ltd. v. State of UP (2010) Allahabad HC Jurisdiction principles in tax adjudication

Between Fine Lines

For businesses, this judgment underscores that writ petitions against GST show cause notices are rarely entertained unless jurisdiction is patently absent. Jurisdictional disputes, scope of penalty under Sections 122(1), 122(1A), and factual allegations like clandestine supplies must be contested during adjudication. The decision aligns with the judiciary’s consistent view that writ courts should not stall tax enquiries at notice stage.

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY