Home Case Laws Challenge to Section 174(2) of GST Act kept open, petitions disposed of...

Challenge to Section 174(2) of GST Act kept open, petitions disposed of subject to Supreme Court’s final decision

0
308

Case Title: Tecnimont SPA India Project Office & Ors. v. State of Punjab & Ors.
Court: High Court of Punjab and Haryana, Chandigarh
Petition Nos.: CWP-18967-2020 (O&M) and 65 connected cases
Date of Judgement: 10 December 2024
Category of Dispute: Constitutional validity – transitional provisions under GST
Relevant Section: Section 174(2), CGST Act 2017 / State GST Acts (Punjab & Haryana)


Facts (Paras 1–3)

Multiple writ petitions were filed by diverse assessees from Punjab, Haryana, and the Union Territory of Chandigarh challenging Section 174(2) of the State Goods and Services Tax Acts, 2017. This provision preserves the power of the pre-GST tax authorities to initiate and continue proceedings under the erstwhile VAT and other repealed laws. Petitioners contended that such saving clause violated the constitutional scheme of GST and exceeded the legislative competence of the States once the concurrent GST regime came into force.

The same provision had earlier been challenged before the Kerala High Court, which upheld its constitutional validity in favour of the Revenue. That ruling was carried in appeal to the Supreme Court through C.A. No. 6724 of 2024 [SLP (C) No. 640 of 2023 – T.S. Belaraman v. Commercial Tax Officer & Ors.], where leave was granted on 14 May 2024 and interim protection was extended restraining coercive steps by the Revenue.


Questions Before the Court (Para 1–2)

Whether Section 174(2) of the State GST Acts, 2017 — which saves pending or past proceedings under repealed laws — is constitutionally valid and within the legislative competence of the respective States post-GST introduction?


Observations (Paras 3–6)

The Division Bench noted that the identical question of law is already under active consideration before the Supreme Court. Since the apex court has granted leave and continued interim restraint against coercive recovery, the High Court found it appropriate not to re-examine the issue independently.

The Bench emphasized that until the Supreme Court finally decides T.S. Belaraman, any adjudication at the High Court level would lead to conflicting positions across States. Therefore, judicial propriety warranted that the matter await final pronouncement by the Supreme Court.


Judgement (Paras 5–8)

All the writ petitions challenging Section 174(2) were disposed of with the direction that their outcome shall abide by the final judgment of the Supreme Court in T.S. Belaraman (supra).
All interim orders previously granted in each individual petition shall continue to operate until the Supreme Court delivers its decision.

Accordingly, all pending miscellaneous applications were also disposed of.


Summary of Key Case Referred

Case Name Court Issue Verdict
T.S. Belaraman v. Commercial Tax Officer & Ors. (CA 6724 / 2024; SLP (C) 640 / 2023) Supreme Court of India Constitutional validity of Section 174(2) Kerala SGST Act 2017 – saving of pre-GST powers Leave granted on 14 May 2024; interim order restraining coercive action; final adjudication pending

Between Fine Lines – Trade & Industry Takeaway

Businesses that received pre-GST notices or reassessments under old VAT/excise/service tax laws may continue to enjoy protection if their cases involve the saving clause under Section 174(2). Since the Supreme Court will decide the constitutional validity, all pending proceedings in Punjab, Haryana, and Chandigarh are kept in abeyance, providing temporary relief from coercive action. However, the final verdict in T.S. Belaraman will determine whether legacy tax proceedings survive the GST transition.

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY