Case Title: Wilhelmsen Port Services India Pvt. Ltd. and Anr. v. State of West Bengal and Ors.
Court: Calcutta High Court
Petition No.: MAT/319/2025, IA No. CAN/1/2025
Category of Dispute: Input Tax Credit (ITC) – Wrong Head Reporting / Revenue Neutrality
Date of Judgment: 25 March 2025
Relevant Sections: Section 16 and 49 of the CGST Act, 2017; Section 9 of the WBGST Act, 2017; Rules 86 and 88 of the CGST Rules
Facts (Paras 1–3, 6–7)
Wilhelmsen Port Services India Pvt. Ltd., the appellant, challenged an interim direction dated 24 February 2025 passed in WPA 406 of 2025. The Single Bench had ordered the appellant to deposit 10% of the balance tax in dispute as a precondition for stay.
The appellant contended that the dispute arose solely from a clerical error while reporting Input Tax Credit (ITC). Instead of properly claiming ₹ 9,56,429.12 each under CGST and WBGST, the company erroneously entered the total ₹ 19,12,857 under IGST. Consequently, the ITC appeared under the IGST ledger rather than the intended CGST/WBGST heads. The appellant argued that this caused no revenue loss to the Government since the credit existed within the electronic credit ledger, making the situation revenue-neutral.
Questions (Para 1–2, 4–5)
Whether the Court, in an intra-court appeal, should interfere with the Single Bench’s discretionary order requiring 10% pre-deposit; and whether the admitted clerical error in ITC head-wise reporting justified unconditional stay of recovery.
Observations (Paras 4–8)
The Division Bench noted that ordinarily, appellate interference with interim discretionary orders is limited. However, the peculiar facts warranted deviation from the norm. The Bench emphasized that the appellant’s error was merely head-wise misclassification of ITC and did not result in any loss of revenue or fraudulent intent. The matter was clearly revenue-neutral, as the ITC was reflected in the electronic credit ledger of the same registered person. The Court found merit in treating such a case differently to prevent undue hardship.
Judgment (Paras 8–11)
The Division Bench, comprising Chief Justice T. S. Sivagnanam and Justice Chaitali Chatterjee (Das), held that the interim order requiring 10% deposit was unwarranted in this revenue-neutral situation.
Accordingly, the Court:
-
Stayed the operation of the impugned order in the writ petition till its final disposal;
-
Exempted the petitioner from depositing 10% of the disputed tax; and
-
Clarified that this relief was based on peculiar facts and should not be treated as a precedent.
Summary of Cases Referred
| Case | Issue | Verdict / Ratio |
|---|---|---|
| Wilhelmsen Port Services India Pvt. Ltd. v. State of West Bengal (MAT 319/2025) | Wrong reporting of ITC head between CGST/WBGST and IGST | Conditional pre-deposit waived; revenue-neutral error not penalized. |
Between Fine Lines
This decision reinforces that technical reporting errors in ITC allocation, when revenue-neutral and without mala fide intent, should not attract coercive conditions such as mandatory pre-deposit. It encourages a substance-over-form approach, emphasizing fairness in GST proceedings.
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”




