Case Title: Y. Balakrishnan v. Enforcement Officer, SGST Department & Ors.
Court: Kerala High Court
Petition No.: WP(C) No. 30274 of 2024
Date of Judgment: 28.02.2025
Category of Dispute: Confiscation of Goods (Section 130, CGST Act)
Relevant Sections: Section 31, 68, 129 & 130 of the CGST Act, 2017; Rules 46, 47, 48, 138 & 138A of CGST Rules, 2017
Facts of the Case (¶2–5, ¶7)
-
Petitioner, proprietor of Onam Beedi Company, engaged in wholesale and retail of beedis, challenged a confiscation order under Section 130.
-
On 12.08.2024, enforcement intercepted a vehicle carrying 40 bags of beedis with invoices and e-way bills from Tamil Nadu to Kerala.
-
The driver (petitioner’s brother) admitted that 10 bags were to be supplied to a shop at Thiruvalla, not mentioned in any invoice (¶2–3, ¶7).
-
Authorities alleged diversion, issuance of back-dated invoices post-interception, and habitual evasion attempts by petitioner (¶4–5).
-
Petitioner argued that IGST was already paid, documents were in order, and sale in transit is common trade practice. He also alleged denial of cross-examination rights (¶3).
Questions in Consideration (¶6–9, ¶11)
-
Whether a mere route deviation or diversion during transit, despite valid invoices and e-way bills, can justify confiscation under Section 130?
-
Whether subsequent invoices generated after interception vitiate the transaction?
-
Whether writ jurisdiction under Article 226 is maintainable against confiscation orders when statutory remedies exist?
-
Whether denial of cross-examination of driver/third parties vitiates confiscation?
Observations of the Court (¶7–12)
-
Route deviation alone cannot establish tax evasion, traders are free to choose routes (¶7; cited Veer Pratab Singh & Transways India Transport).
-
However, factual questions like delivery to undisclosed shops and post-interception invoices require appreciation of evidence, best left to appellate authority (¶7–9).
-
Payment of IGST does not preclude evasion if goods are moved without proper documentation or through artificial splitting of consignments (¶8–9).
-
Allegation of denial of cross-examination is not sufficient since the driver was petitioner’s brother; such issues can be raised in appeal (¶11).
-
Statutory provisions provide mechanisms for release of goods even after confiscation (¶12).
Judgment of the Court (¶13)
-
High Court dismissed the writ petition, holding that extraordinary jurisdiction under Article 226 should not be exercised.
-
Petitioner relegated to statutory appellate remedy.
-
Period spent in pursuing writ petition shall be excluded from limitation for appeal filing.
Between Fine Lines (Simplified Summary)
-
Route deviation is not automatically tax evasion, but if invoices don’t cover delivery, suspicion is valid.
-
Confiscation orders involve factual disputes; writ courts won’t re-examine evidence.
-
IGST payment doesn’t immunize from liability if documentation lapses exist.
-
Cross-examination claims are not fatal at writ stage; appellate remedy is proper.
-
Petitioner must file an appeal, with exclusion of writ period from limitation.
Summary of Referred Cases
| Case Name | Citation | Summary | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| Veer Pratab Singh v. State of Kerala | (2021) 123 taxmann.com 110 (Kerala) | Held that mere route deviation cannot constitute tax evasion. | Route deviation not sufficient ground for penalty/confiscation. |
| Transways India Transport v. JCCT (Appeals)-3, Bengaluru | (2024) 164 taxmann.com 673 (Karnataka) | Traders are free to choose transport routes. | Confiscation not justified merely for route change. |
| Maa Mahamaya Alloys (P.) Ltd. v. State of U.P. | (2023) 150 taxmann.com 158 (Allahabad) | GST liability arises at point of supply, not earlier. | Favoured taxpayer; but HC distinguished in present case. |
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”




