Home Case Laws Confiscation of Goods – Writ Dismissed, Remedy Lies in Statutory Appeal

Confiscation of Goods – Writ Dismissed, Remedy Lies in Statutory Appeal

0
224

Case Title: Y. Balakrishnan v. Enforcement Officer, SGST Department & Ors.
Court: Kerala High Court
Petition No.: WP(C) No. 30274 of 2024
Date of Judgment: 28.02.2025
Category of Dispute: Confiscation of Goods (Section 130, CGST Act)
Relevant Sections: Section 31, 68, 129 & 130 of the CGST Act, 2017; Rules 46, 47, 48, 138 & 138A of CGST Rules, 2017


Facts of the Case (¶2–5, ¶7)

  • Petitioner, proprietor of Onam Beedi Company, engaged in wholesale and retail of beedis, challenged a confiscation order under Section 130.

  • On 12.08.2024, enforcement intercepted a vehicle carrying 40 bags of beedis with invoices and e-way bills from Tamil Nadu to Kerala.

  • The driver (petitioner’s brother) admitted that 10 bags were to be supplied to a shop at Thiruvalla, not mentioned in any invoice (¶2–3, ¶7).

  • Authorities alleged diversion, issuance of back-dated invoices post-interception, and habitual evasion attempts by petitioner (¶4–5).

  • Petitioner argued that IGST was already paid, documents were in order, and sale in transit is common trade practice. He also alleged denial of cross-examination rights (¶3).


Questions in Consideration (¶6–9, ¶11)

  1. Whether a mere route deviation or diversion during transit, despite valid invoices and e-way bills, can justify confiscation under Section 130?

  2. Whether subsequent invoices generated after interception vitiate the transaction?

  3. Whether writ jurisdiction under Article 226 is maintainable against confiscation orders when statutory remedies exist?

  4. Whether denial of cross-examination of driver/third parties vitiates confiscation?


Observations of the Court (¶7–12)

  • Route deviation alone cannot establish tax evasion, traders are free to choose routes (¶7; cited Veer Pratab Singh & Transways India Transport).

  • However, factual questions like delivery to undisclosed shops and post-interception invoices require appreciation of evidence, best left to appellate authority (¶7–9).

  • Payment of IGST does not preclude evasion if goods are moved without proper documentation or through artificial splitting of consignments (¶8–9).

  • Allegation of denial of cross-examination is not sufficient since the driver was petitioner’s brother; such issues can be raised in appeal (¶11).

  • Statutory provisions provide mechanisms for release of goods even after confiscation (¶12).


Judgment of the Court (¶13)

  • High Court dismissed the writ petition, holding that extraordinary jurisdiction under Article 226 should not be exercised.

  • Petitioner relegated to statutory appellate remedy.

  • Period spent in pursuing writ petition shall be excluded from limitation for appeal filing.


Between Fine Lines (Simplified Summary)

  • Route deviation is not automatically tax evasion, but if invoices don’t cover delivery, suspicion is valid.

  • Confiscation orders involve factual disputes; writ courts won’t re-examine evidence.

  • IGST payment doesn’t immunize from liability if documentation lapses exist.

  • Cross-examination claims are not fatal at writ stage; appellate remedy is proper.

  • Petitioner must file an appeal, with exclusion of writ period from limitation.


Summary of Referred Cases

Case Name Citation Summary Verdict
Veer Pratab Singh v. State of Kerala (2021) 123 taxmann.com 110 (Kerala) Held that mere route deviation cannot constitute tax evasion. Route deviation not sufficient ground for penalty/confiscation.
Transways India Transport v. JCCT (Appeals)-3, Bengaluru (2024) 164 taxmann.com 673 (Karnataka) Traders are free to choose transport routes. Confiscation not justified merely for route change.
Maa Mahamaya Alloys (P.) Ltd. v. State of U.P. (2023) 150 taxmann.com 158 (Allahabad) GST liability arises at point of supply, not earlier. Favoured taxpayer; but HC distinguished in present case.

 

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY