Home Case Laws Confiscation Order Quashed for Lack of Hearing Opportunity

Confiscation Order Quashed for Lack of Hearing Opportunity

0
191

Case Details:
Case Name: M/s Gajanand Granite v. Office of State Tax Officer, Dehradun
Court: High Court of Uttarakhand, Nainital
Petition No.: Writ Petition (M/B) No. 358 of 2025
Date of Judgment: 12th June 2025
Bench: Hon’ble Chief Justice Sri G. Narendar and Hon’ble Sri Justice Alok Mahra
Category of Dispute: Confiscation of Goods
Relevant Section: Section 130(4) of the CGST Act, 2017


📌 Between Fine Lines:

  • Confiscation and penalty proceedings must comply with principles of natural justice.

  • Orders passed without granting hearing are unsustainable under Section 130(4) of CGST Act.

  • Reply by the truck driver cannot substitute a proper response from the taxpayer.

  • The entire penalty process completed on the same day is a violation of due process.

  • Matter remitted back to issue a proper show cause notice and allow opportunity of hearing.


🧾 Facts of the Case:

  • [Para 2] The petitioner’s lorry transporting goods was intercepted by the GST authorities.

  • [Para 2] A show-cause notice was issued and entire proceedings—inspection, penalty, fine, and confiscation—were concluded the same day.

  • [Para 2] The driver, not connected to the goods, was considered the respondent; the petitioner was not afforded an opportunity of hearing.


❓Question(s) in Consideration:

  • [Para 2] Whether the confiscation and penalty order passed without giving the petitioner an opportunity to be heard, solely relying on a reply by the vehicle driver, is valid under Section 130(4) of the CGST Act, 2017?


🔍 Observation of Court:

  • [Para 4] The Court held that such action is arbitrary and contrary to Section 130(4) of CGST Act, which mandates an opportunity of hearing before any order of confiscation or penalty.

  • [Para 3] The State admitted the entire process was completed on the same day, validating the petitioner’s claims of procedural irregularity.


⚖️ Judgment of the Court:

  • [Para 5] The confiscation and penalty order was set aside for violation of natural justice and statutory provisions.

  • [Para 5] The matter was remitted to the Deputy Commissioner, Commercial Tax, Dehradun to initiate proceedings afresh from the stage of show-cause notice.

  • [Para 6] No order as to costs; all miscellaneous petitions closed.


📚 Summary of Referred Cases:

Name Citation Summary Verdict
None referred in the judgment — — —

LEAVE A REPLY