Case: CP Wholesale India Private Limited v. Pr. CIT
Tribunal: Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Delhi, “A” Bench
Citation: ITA No. 4942/Del/2026
Assessment Year: 2020-21
Coram: Shri Anubhav Sharma, Judicial Member and Shri Sanjay Awasthi, Accountant Member
Date of Pronouncement: 7 August 2026
Category: Income Tax – Revision under Section 263 – Share Capital – Section 68
Core Issue
Whether the Principal Commissioner of Income Tax could invoke revisionary jurisdiction under Section 263 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 and direct a deeper inquiry into the creditworthiness of a shareholder where the Assessing Officer had already raised specific queries regarding the share capital transaction, examined the supporting material furnished by the assessee and accepted the transaction without making an addition under Section 68.
Brief Facts
CP Wholesale India Private Limited’s return for Assessment Year 2020-21 was selected for scrutiny. During the assessment proceedings, the Assessing Officer issued questionnaires under Section 142(1) seeking details concerning the issuance of share capital, valuation and the creditworthiness of the investor.
The assessee furnished information concerning its non-resident shareholder, Makro ROH Company Limited, including its identity, business particulars, financial statements, income-tax return, net worth, banking documents evidencing outward remittances and correspondence relating to the investment.
The assessment was completed on 23 November 2023 under Section 143(3) read with Sections 144C(3) and 144B. The Assessing Officer made an addition relating only to transfer pricing adjustment and did not make any addition under Section 68 in respect of the share capital.
The PCIT subsequently invoked Section 263 and held that a deeper inquiry into the creditworthiness of the investor was required. The Assessing Officer was directed to re-examine the matter with reference to the requirements of Section 68. The assessee challenged the revisionary order before the ITAT.
ITAT’s Findings
The Tribunal noted that the Assessing Officer had specifically examined the issuance of share capital not only in the context of Section 56(2)(viib), but also with reference to Section 68. The assessee had responded to the queries and furnished material relating to the identity, genuineness and creditworthiness of the investor.
The Tribunal further observed that Makro ROH was the assessee’s existing shareholder and immediate parent company. The assessee had furnished its Thai corporate registration particulars, director details, income-tax return, audited financial statements, bank documents showing remittances through regular banking channels and contemporaneous correspondence relating to the share subscription.
The same shareholder and similar share capital transactions had also been examined in earlier assessment years, namely Assessment Years 2017-18 and 2018-19, without any adverse inference being drawn.
The Tribunal held that the mere absence of an elaborate discussion in the assessment order does not establish that the Assessing Officer failed to conduct an inquiry. Whether an inquiry was undertaken has to be determined from the entire assessment record and not merely from the contents of the final assessment order.
Lack of Inquiry Distinguished from Inadequate Inquiry
Relying upon the principles laid down by the Delhi High Court in CIT v. Sunbeam Auto Ltd. and CIT v. Vikas Polymers, the Tribunal reiterated that there is a material distinction between lack of inquiry and inadequate inquiry.
Where an Assessing Officer has raised queries, considered the assessee’s responses and taken a possible view, the PCIT cannot invoke Section 263 merely because he believes that a more detailed or deeper inquiry should have been conducted.
The revisionary authority cannot substitute its own opinion regarding the manner or sufficiency of inquiry merely because it would have approached the matter differently.
Requirement of Independent Inquiry by PCIT
The Tribunal observed that if the PCIT considers the inquiry conducted by the Assessing Officer inadequate and proposes to hold the assessment order erroneous, the PCIT must undertake the necessary inquiry and record a categorical finding demonstrating the error in the assessment order.
Merely directing the Assessing Officer to re-examine the same material without first establishing how the original assessment order is erroneous and prejudicial to the interests of the Revenue does not satisfy the requirements of Section 263.
The Tribunal relied, inter alia, upon Malabar Industrial Co. Ltd. v. CIT, PCIT v. Delhi Airport Metro Express Pvt. Ltd. and ITO v. D.G. Housing Projects Ltd. for the applicable principles governing revisionary jurisdiction.
Ratio Decidendi
Section 263 cannot be invoked merely because the PCIT considers that the Assessing Officer should have conducted a deeper or more exhaustive inquiry. Where the assessment record demonstrates that specific queries were raised, relevant evidence was furnished and considered, and the Assessing Officer adopted a permissible view, the assessment order cannot be treated as erroneous merely because the PCIT holds a different opinion regarding the adequacy of the inquiry.
Where inadequate inquiry, rather than complete absence of inquiry, is alleged, the PCIT must himself undertake the necessary verification and establish by a clear finding that the assessment order is erroneous and prejudicial to the interests of the Revenue before directing reconsideration by the Assessing Officer.
Final Verdict
The ITAT held that the Assessing Officer had conducted inquiries regarding the share capital and the creditworthiness of the investor and had considered the material furnished by the assessee.
The PCIT had sought a further or “deeper inquiry” without demonstrating through his own inquiry how the Assessing Officer’s conclusion was erroneous or unsustainable in law.
Accordingly, the Tribunal sustained the assessee’s grounds of appeal and quashed the order passed under Section 263.
Appeal Allowed.
Key Takeaway
Revision under Section 263 cannot be used merely to compel the Assessing Officer to conduct a deeper inquiry into an issue already examined during assessment. Where inquiries were made and relevant evidence was considered, the PCIT must independently establish an error in the assessment order; a different opinion regarding the adequacy of inquiry is insufficient.




