Home Updates Daily Tax Law Briefing – GST & Income Tax | 03 August...

Daily Tax Law Briefing – GST & Income Tax | 03 August 2026

0
106

The Daily Tax Law Briefing – 03 August 2026 presents the latest judicial developments under the Goods and Services Tax (GST) and the Income-tax Act, 1961. This edition analyses seven significant judicial pronouncements, comprising two GST judgments and five Income Tax decisions, delivered by the Delhi High Court and various Benches of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal at Bengaluru, Hyderabad, Delhi and Surat. The rulings examine important issues relating to GST appellate pre-deposit, summons issued to advocates, taxation of online gaming winnings, search assessments, Section 50C valuation, reassessment jurisdiction and taxation of employee stock options.

The GST section is led by the Delhi High Court’s decision in Gaurav Jain & Anr. v. Joint Commissioner (Appeals-II), CGST Delhi Zone. The Court held that the right of appeal is a vested substantive right that accrues when the lis commences, namely on the issuance of the show cause notice. Since the proceedings in the case commenced before the substituted proviso to Section 107(6) of the CGST Act came into force on 1 October 2025, the newly introduced requirement of depositing 10% of the penalty for appeals against penalty-only orders could not be applied retrospectively. The Court directed the appellate authority to entertain the appeals without insisting on the amended pre-deposit requirement while leaving the constitutional validity of the amended provision open for consideration in an appropriate case.

Another important GST ruling comes from Lalitendra Gulani v. Director General, Directorate of Revenue Intelligence, where the Delhi High Court considered the issuance of summons under Section 108 of the Customs Act, 1962 to an Advocate who had rendered a legal opinion. Although the impugned summons had already been withdrawn, the Court observed that advocates should ordinarily be summoned only in rare and exceptional circumstances. The Court emphasised that authorities must exercise due care and caution while issuing summons seeking disclosure of legal opinions or privileged professional communications.

The Income Tax section features five noteworthy judicial pronouncements dealing with online gaming taxation, search assessments, valuation, reassessment and employee stock options. In Arakere Channappa Vishwanath v. ITO, the ITAT Bengaluru held that only real income can be taxed and not the gross circulation of funds within an online gaming wallet. Referring to the legislative framework introduced by the Finance Act, 2023, including Sections 194BA and 115BBJ, the Tribunal held that only net winnings from online games are taxable. Since the evidence established that the assessee had incurred an overall net loss after considering buy-in amounts, the addition based on gross wallet credits was deleted.

In Clarion Agro Products Private Limited, the ITAT Hyderabad upheld the addition relating to unexplained cash found during a search while clarifying that technical objections regarding approval under Section 153D, including absence of DIN and incorrect reference to Section 69 instead of Section 69A, could not invalidate the assessment in view of the retrospective insertion of Section 292BC by the Finance Act, 2026. However, the Tribunal remanded the issue relating to excess stock for fresh verification after granting adequate opportunity to the assessee.

The briefing also includes an important decision of the ITAT Delhi in Consolidated Finvest and Holdings Limited, where the Tribunal held that the specific mechanism under Section 50C(2) overrides the general valuation provisions under Section 142A. Since the Assessing Officer completed the assessment without obtaining the Departmental Valuation Officer’s report and wrongly claimed an extended limitation period, the assessment was held to be barred by limitation and the addition under Section 50C was set aside.

Further, the ITAT Surat in Hiteshkumar Poptabhai Borad quashed reassessment proceedings after holding that approval under Section 151(ii) must be obtained from the competent authority where more than three years have elapsed from the end of the relevant assessment year. Approval granted by the Principal Commissioner instead of the prescribed authority rendered the reassessment without jurisdiction. The Tribunal also held that the amendment introduced by the Finance Act, 2023 could not retrospectively validate the proceedings.

The briefing concludes with the ITAT Bengaluru’s decision in Pramod Kumar Jain, where the Tribunal held that consideration received on the repurchase of unexercised employee stock options cannot be taxed as a perquisite under Section 17(2)(vi) because no shares were ever allotted. The vested stock options constituted a capital asset, and their repurchase amounted to a transfer taxable as Long-Term Capital Gains under Section 45. The Tribunal clarified that Form 16, TDS deduction or contractual tax clauses cannot determine the correct legal character of income.

The Daily Tax Law Briefing – 03 August 2026 serves as a valuable resource for advocates, chartered accountants, company secretaries, tax consultants, businesses and corporate tax teams seeking concise updates on the latest judicial developments. It provides practical guidance on GST appellate rights, professional privilege, online gaming taxation, reassessment jurisdiction, valuation disputes and employee stock option taxation, enabling professionals to stay informed of significant judicial trends.

Download the complete Daily Tax Law Briefing (3 August 2026)

LEAVE A REPLY