The Daily Tax Law Briefing – 16 July 2026 presents a comprehensive overview of the latest judicial developments under the Goods and Services Tax (GST) and Income-tax laws. This edition analyses significant rulings delivered by the GST Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT), Gujarat High Court, Andhra Pradesh High Court, Delhi High Court, Bombay High Court and the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, covering important issues relating to anti-profiteering, writ jurisdiction, validity of assessment orders, GST refunds, reassessment proceedings, limitation and principles of natural justice.
The GST section features four important judgments addressing key aspects of GST litigation. The GST Appellate Tribunal has upheld the DGAP’s methodology for determining profiteering under Section 171 of the CGST Act, directing the developer to pass on the remaining ITC benefit with interest to eligible homebuyers while clarifying that excess benefit given to some buyers cannot be adjusted against the shortfall payable to others. The Gujarat High Court has reiterated that where an effective statutory appeal under Section 107 is available and adequate opportunity of hearing has been provided, the High Court will ordinarily decline to exercise writ jurisdiction over disputed factual issues.
Another significant ruling of the Andhra Pradesh High Court holds that an unsigned assessment order is invalid and cannot be treated as validly served under the CGST Act and Rules. The Court directed the department to undertake a fresh assessment after issuing a duly signed order. The Delhi High Court also directed release of a GST refund amount deposited with the Registrar General, observing that in the absence of any interim restraint by the Appellate Tribunal there was no legal impediment to releasing the refund, subject to further orders in the pending appeal.
The Income Tax section analyses four noteworthy judgments covering reassessment, limitation, transfer pricing and natural justice. The ITAT Delhi has held that where accommodation entries are established, only the profit element embedded in such transactions should be brought to tax rather than the entire differential amount. The Bombay High Court has reaffirmed that the relevant date for limitation is the date on which an assessment order is digitally signed and comes into legal existence, resulting in the reassessment order being quashed as time-barred. Similarly, the ITAT Delhi has held that an assessment order becomes complete only upon digital signature and consequently quashed a transfer pricing assessment that was digitally signed after expiry of the statutory limitation period.
The Bombay High Court has further strengthened the principles of natural justice by holding that where the final assessment order travels substantially beyond the proposal contained in the original show cause notice, the assessee must be given an effective opportunity to respond. The Court therefore quashed the assessment order and directed the tax department to issue a fresh opportunity of hearing before passing a revised assessment.
This edition provides valuable guidance on GST anti-profiteering, assessment procedures, refund jurisprudence, limitation, digital authentication of assessment orders and procedural fairness. It serves as a practical resource for advocates, chartered accountants, company secretaries, tax consultants, businesses and corporate tax teams seeking to remain updated with the latest judicial trends in indirect and direct taxation.
Download the complete Daily Tax Law Briefing (16 July 2026)




