The Daily Tax Law Briefing – 30 July 2026 highlights two significant judicial pronouncements under the Income-tax Act, 1961, delivered by the Bombay High Court and the Supreme Court of India. These decisions examine important principles relating to prosecution for tax evasion under Section 276C(2), the requirement of mens rea, the scope of Section 44B governing presumptive taxation of non-resident shipping businesses, and deduction of tax at source under Section 195.
The first judgment, delivered by the Bombay High Court in Ms. Dinar Tarcar Resources (India) Pvt. Ltd. v. Income Tax Department, provides important guidance on criminal prosecution for alleged tax evasion. The Court held that prosecution under Section 276C(2) can be sustained only where there is a wilful attempt to evade payment of tax, which necessarily requires proof of mens rea. Merely delaying payment of tax, particularly where the assessee repeatedly sought time, ultimately discharged the entire tax liability together with interest and penalty, and no false entries or deliberate acts of concealment were alleged, does not satisfy the ingredients of the offence. Since the complaint contained only vague allegations and the Magistrate issued process mechanically without examining whether the statutory ingredients existed, the Court quashed the criminal proceedings and set aside the order issuing process.
The second judgment is the Supreme Court’s decision in Director of Income Tax (International Taxation) v. Star Cruises (India) Pvt. Ltd. concerning the taxation of non-resident cruise operators. The Revenue contended that cruise operations involved hospitality and entertainment rather than carriage of passengers and therefore should not qualify for presumptive taxation under Section 44B. Rejecting this contention, the Supreme Court held that operating cruise vessels, including round trips and voyages permitting passengers to disembark at intermediate ports, constitutes the operation of ships and falls squarely within the scope of Section 44B. The Court observed that ancillary hospitality and entertainment services do not alter the essential character of the business. Accordingly, the statutory presumptive income rate of 7.5% under Section 44B was held to be applicable, and the Revenue’s appeals were dismissed.
These rulings reinforce two important principles of tax jurisprudence. First, criminal prosecution under the Income-tax Act cannot proceed without establishing a deliberate and wilful intention to evade tax. Secondly, beneficial presumptive taxation provisions must receive a practical and purposive interpretation consistent with the true nature of the taxpayer’s business rather than a narrow or restrictive construction. Together, these judgments provide valuable guidance for taxpayers, tax professionals and litigation practitioners dealing with prosecution proceedings, international taxation and shipping-related income.
The Daily Tax Law Briefing – 30 July 2026 serves as a concise resource for advocates, chartered accountants, company secretaries, tax consultants, businesses and corporate tax teams seeking to remain updated with the latest judicial developments under the Income-tax Act.




