Home Case Laws Delhi HC Remands GST ITC & Reconciliation Dispute for Fresh Adjudication

Delhi HC Remands GST ITC & Reconciliation Dispute for Fresh Adjudication

0
423

Case Details:

  • Case Name: Charu Overseas Pvt. Ltd. v. Pr. Commissioner of Delhi GST & Ors.

  • Court: High Court of Delhi

  • Petition No.: W.P.(C) 9546/2024 & CM APPL. 39114/2024

  • Judgment Date: 06.05.2025

  • Coram: Justice Prathiba M. Singh & Justice Rajneesh Kumar Gupta

  • Category: Input Tax Credit / Procedural Lapse / Validity of Notifications

  • Relevant Sections: Section 73, Section 168A CGST Act, Rule 60(6) CGST Rules

  • Related Notifications: 09/2023-CT (31.03.2023) & 56/2023-CT (28.12.2023)

  • Connected Supreme Court Case: SLP No. 4240/2025 – M/s HCC-SEW-MEIL-AAG JV v. ACST & Ors.


Facts of the Case

(Ref.: Paras 2, 3, 6, 7)

  1. Petitioner challenged SCNs dated 09.12.2023 and 25.01.2024 and consequent adjudication orders dated 10.04.2024 & 30.04.2024 under Section 73 CGST/SGST Act.

  2. First SCN alleged wrongful ITC claim; second SCN related to mismatch between GSTR-3B & GSTR-2A based on special audit.

  3. Petitioner claimed reply to first SCN was ignored; for second SCN (FY 2018-19), IGST import/SEZ data was unavailable until Rule 60(6) came into force on 01.01.2021.

  4. Challenge also made to CBIC Notifications 09/2023 & 56/2023 issued under Section 168A CGST Act extending adjudication limitation, alleging procedural lapses.


Question(s) in Consideration

(Ref.: Paras 4, 5, 6, 10, 15)

  1. Whether adjudication orders passed without due consideration of replies and opportunity of hearing are valid.

  2. Whether limitation for adjudication under Section 73 for FY 2019-20 could be extended via Notifications 09/2023 & 56/2023 under Section 168A CGST Act.

  3. Whether absence of IGST import/SEZ reporting utility in FY 2018-19 impacts reconciliation-based demand.


Observations of the Court

(Ref.: Paras 8–13)

  1. Validity of Notifications 09/2023 & 56/2023 is pending before the Supreme Court; multiple High Courts have divergent views.

  2. Even if notifications are upheld, factual grievances such as denial of hearing and non-consideration of replies need redressal.

  3. Issue of IGST import/SEZ data unavailability at the relevant time under Rule 60(6) requires specific adjudicating authority consideration.

  4. Passing of two separate orders for SCNs before the same authority was noted; department to consider issuing a single order in such cases.


Judgment of the Court

(Ref.: Paras 11–16)

  1. Impugned adjudication orders set aside; both SCNs remanded to the adjudicating authority for fresh consideration on merits.

  2. Petitioner allowed to file additional reply by 10.07.2025; personal hearing to be granted and single adjudication order to be passed.

  3. GST portal access to be ensured for the petitioner.

  4. Validity of notifications left open; adjudicating authority’s decision will be subject to SC outcome in SLP No. 4240/2025.

  5. Petition disposed with all rights and remedies reserved.


Between Fine Lines

  • Delhi HC did not decide the legality of GST deadline extension notifications—left to SC.

  • Fresh hearing ordered due to denial of proper opportunity and unresolved procedural issues.

  • IGST import/SEZ data gap for FY 2018-19 is a valid defence point.

  • SCNs to be consolidated into a single order to avoid multiplicity.

  • This ensures taxpayer’s right to fair hearing before tax demands are finalised.


Summary of Referred Cases

Case Name & Citation Summary Verdict
DJST Traders Pvt. Ltd. v. UOI & Ors. (Delhi HC) Lead matter challenging Notifications 09/2023 & 56/2023 under Section 168A CGST Act. Pending before SC.
Allahabad HC – Notification 09/2023 Challenge to limitation extension upheld. Notification valid.
Patna HC – Notification 56/2023 Limitation extension upheld. Notification valid.
Guwahati HC – Notification 56/2023 Held limitation extension invalid. Notification quashed.
Telangana HC – HCC-SEW-MEIL-AAG JV Made adverse observations on Notification 56/2023 without deciding vires; now before SC in SLP 4240/2025. Pending SC decision.
Punjab & Haryana HC Refrained from deciding vires due to SC pendency; interim orders to continue till SC decision. Awaiting SC verdict.

 

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY