Case Details
-
Case Name: Brij Machine Tools v. Govt. of NCT of Delhi & Ors.
-
Court: High Court of Delhi
-
Petition No.: W.P.(C) 14654/2024
-
Date of Judgement: 23rd April 2025 (corrected & released on 28th April 2025)
-
Coram: Justice Prathiba M. Singh & Justice Rajneesh Kumar Gupta
-
Relevant Sections: Section 73, Section 168A CGST/DGST Act, 2017; Article 226 of Constitution of India
-
Category of Dispute: Validity of Notification & Principles of Natural Justice (SCN & Personal Hearing)
Facts of the Case
-
The Petitioner challenged (i) SCN dated 20.12.2023 for FY 2018-19, (ii) adjudication order dated 09.04.2024 passed under Section 73 CGST/DGST Act, and (iii) Notification No. 56/2023-Central Tax dated 28.12.2023. (Para 2, 3)
-
The SCN was only uploaded under “Additional Notices Tab” on GST portal and not communicated properly, leading to no reply and no appearance by Petitioner. (Para 6)
-
The impugned order was passed ex-parte without personal hearing. (Para 6)
-
The challenge to Notification 56/2023 was already pending before the Supreme Court in SLP No. 4240/2025 (M/s HCC-SEW-MEIL-AAG JV v. AC State Tax). (Para 5)
Question(s) in Consideration
-
Whether SCN uploaded only in “Additional Notices Tab” without due visibility amounts to denial of natural justice? (Para 6–7)
-
Whether the adjudication order passed ex-parte without hearing could be sustained? (Para 6)
-
Whether challenge to Notification 56/2023 should be adjudicated by the High Court when matter is sub judice before Supreme Court? (Para 5, 10)
Observations of Court
-
Various High Courts have taken conflicting views on validity of Notifications 9/2023 & 56/2023 under Section 168A, and matter is pending before the Supreme Court. Hence, validity of Notification 56/2023 not decided in this petition. (Para 5, 10)
-
Court noted earlier Delhi HC rulings (Neelgiri Machinery, Satish Chand Mittal, Anant Wire Industries) where SCNs were hidden under “Additional Notices Tab” and remand was directed. (Para 7)
-
Since changes in portal visibility were made only post January 2024, SCN of December 2023 was not visible, thereby denying opportunity to the Petitioner. (Para 8)
Judgement of the Court
-
The impugned adjudication order dated 09.04.2024 is set aside. (Para 8)
-
Petitioner permitted to file reply within 30 days; adjudicating authority to grant personal hearing and decide afresh. (Para 9)
-
Hearing notices must be emailed to Petitioner in addition to portal upload. (Para 7)
-
Challenge to Notification 56/2023 kept open; any fresh order shall remain subject to outcome of Supreme Court decision in SLP 4240/2025. (Para 10)
Between Fine Lines
-
The Court did not decide validity of Notification 56/2023 as it is pending before SC.
-
Ex-parte orders based only on portal uploads under “Additional Notices Tab” violate natural justice.
-
Adjudication orders must be preceded by proper communication of SCNs and hearings.
-
Notices must now be both uploaded and emailed to ensure visibility.
-
The matter is remanded for fresh decision with due hearing rights.
Summary of Referred Cases
| Case Name | Citation / W.P. No. | Summary | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| DJST Traders Pvt Ltd v. UOI & Ors. | W.P.(C) 16499/2023 (Delhi HC) | Lead petition challenging Notifications 9/2023 & 56/2023 under Sec. 168A CGST Act. | Pending; linked with SC SLP 4240/2025. |
| M/s HCC-SEW-MEIL-AAG JV v. AC State Tax | SLP 4240/2025 (SC) | Challenge to extension of time limits under Sec. 168A via Notifications 9 & 56/2023. | Pending before SC. |
| Neelgiri Machinery v. Commissioner DGST | W.P.(C) 13727/2024 (Delhi HC) | SCN uploaded under “Additional Notices Tab” not visible; ex-parte order passed. | Order set aside, remanded for hearing. |
| Satish Chand Mittal v. Sales Tax Officer SGST | W.P.(C) 12589/2024 (Delhi HC) | SCN & orders unsigned and hidden under additional tab. | Order set aside, matter remanded. |
| Anant Wire Industries v. Sales Tax Officer | W.P.(C) 17867/2024 (Delhi HC) | Similar facts of hidden SCN and lack of hearing. | Order remanded for fresh adjudication. |
| M/s ACE Cardiopathy Solutions Pvt Ltd v. UOI | Neutral Citation No. 2024:DHC:4108-DB | Issue of hidden SCN addressed; opportunity of hearing required. | Relief granted; remand. |
| Kamla Vohra v. Sales Tax Officer | Neutral Citation No. 2024:DHC:5108-DB | Lack of proper service of SCN violates natural justice. | Matter remanded. |
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”




