Case Title: M/s Sri Sai Food Grain and Iron Stores v. State of Bihar
Court: Patna High Court
Petition No.: CWJC No. 13674 of 2024
Category: Search and Seizure – Demand Order under Section 74
Judgment Date: 25 April 2025
Relevant Sections: Section 67 and Section 74 of CGST/BGST Act, 2017; Section 100 of CrPC, 1973
Judges: Hon’ble Mr. Justice P.B. Bajanthri and Hon’ble Mr. Justice Alok Kumar Sinha
🧾 Facts of the Case [¶ 2–3, 4–6]
-
The petitioner, a GST-registered proprietary concern, was subjected to an inspection on 18.01.2024 by the Assistant Commissioner (Ms. Kumari Anu Soni), who also prepared a seizure order.
-
The seizure order was later found to be tampered by inserting the phrase “As Per Physical Verification” after the matter became sub-judice.
-
The officer admitted the tampering before the court, apologized, and submitted an affidavit acknowledging her lack of experience in search and seizure procedures.
-
A demand order dated 09.05.2024 for ₹88,64,550.50 was issued under Section 74(9) of the CGST/BGST Act based on this inspection.
❓Questions in Consideration [¶ 4–8]
-
Whether the inspection and seizure conducted on 18.01.2024 complied with Section 67 of the CGST/BGST Act, 2017 and Section 100 of CrPC, 1973?
-
Whether tampering of the seizure order renders the entire demand illegal and unsustainable?
🧭 Observations of the Court
-
Tampering of Record: The Court found prima facie evidence of interpolation in the seizure order, admitted by the officer involved [¶ 2–3].
-
Violation of Section 67 CGST/BGST: The inspection lacked signatures of two independent witnesses as mandated under Section 100 CrPC and para 2(vii) of CBIC Instructions No. 01/2020-21 [¶ 7].
-
Fabricated Witness Details: The names of unrelated persons as “independent witnesses” in the seizure order appeared to be afterthoughts as they were neither present in the inspection report nor did they sign any contemporaneous documents [¶ 7].
-
No Contemporaneity: The seizure order lacked correlation with the inspection report—no signatures of the persons on site, nor any date/time reference connecting both documents [¶ 7–8].
🏛 Judgment of the Court [¶ 9–10]
-
The demand order dated 09.05.2024 is quashed as it is based on an invalid and tampered seizure order and an inspection that violated statutory safeguards.
-
Ms. Kumari Anu Soni is admonished with a warning that future misconduct shall result in disciplinary proceedings.
-
The writ petition is allowed and pending interlocutory applications disposed of.
📌 Between Fine Lines
-
A seizure order tampered after initiation of legal proceedings undermines the entire foundation of any consequential demand.
-
Inspections under Section 67 must strictly follow CrPC safeguards including presence and attestation by two independent witnesses.
-
Mentioning unrelated or absent individuals as “witnesses” in records without corroborating signatures is legally unacceptable.
-
Courts are willing to grant leniency for first-time procedural lapses but only with stern warnings.
-
Procedural fairness and integrity of records are critical in upholding tax demands under GST law.
📚 Summary of Referred Cases
| Name | Citation | Summary | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| CBIC Instruction No. 01/2020-21 | CBIC | Mandates procedural safeguards during search under GST law including witness attestation | Court followed it to declare the search invalid due to non-compliance |
| Section 100 of CrPC | CrPC, 1973 | Requires two independent witnesses during search and seizure | Applied to GST inspection to test validity of proceedings |
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”




