Case Title: Bright Road Logistics v. Commercial Tax Officer (Enforcement – 09)
Court: High Court of Karnataka
Petition Number: Writ Petition No. 50631 of 2019 (T-RES)
Category of Dispute: Detention and Release of Conveyance – Section 129
Date of Judgment: November 12, 2019
Relevant Sections: Section 129(1)(b) of the CGST Act, 2017 and Karnataka GST Act, 2017
Presiding Judge: Mrs. S. Sujatha, J.
Facts of the Case
- Petitioner Bright Road Logistics, a GST-registered transporter, was engaged by M/s. Bhima Trading Company (Tamil Nadu) to transport scrap to M/s. Rajendra Traders (New Delhi). [Para 2]
- The transport vehicle was intercepted on 02.10.2019 by the Enforcement Officer on Tumkur Road, Bengaluru, and documents including E-way bill and invoice were produced. [Para 2]
- The officer doubted the origin of goods and passed an order of detention under Section 129(1) in Form GST MOV-09. [Para 2]
- A show-cause notice under Section 129(1)(b) was issued on the ground that the consignor was non-existent. [Para 2]
- The petitioner filed objections and requested a hearing, but the officer dismissed the petitioner’s locus standi, stating the transporter could not represent consignor or consignee. [Para 3]
Questions in Consideration
- Whether the transporter has the locus standi to respond to a show-cause notice under Section 129(1)(b) when such a notice is issued to them. [Para 4]
- Whether the impugned order passed without hearing the petitioner violates principles of natural justice. [Para 4]
Observation of the Court
- Once a show-cause notice under Section 129(1)(b) was issued to the transporter, the respondent could not later deny the transporter’s right to respond or participate in the proceedings. [Para 6]
- Denial of hearing despite issuance of notice amounted to a violation of natural justice. [Para 6]
- The quasi-judicial authority is bound to provide fair opportunity and hear objections from parties it issues notices to. [Para 6]
Judgment of the Court
- The impugned order dated 22.10.2019 was quashed for being arbitrary and in violation of natural justice. [Para 8]
- The petitioner was granted liberty to file further objections within 10 days. [Para 7]
- The respondent was directed to reconsider the matter after affording reasonable opportunity of hearing and to pass a fresh order. [Para 8]
- The writ petition was disposed of with liberty to both parties to raise contentions afresh. [Para 10]
Between Fine Lines
- A transporter who receives a notice under Section 129(1)(b) has the right to respond.
- Authorities cannot later question the transporter’s locus standi after initiating proceedings.
- Fair hearing is a basic requirement under natural justice.
- GST authorities must follow due process before confirming penalties or detention orders.
- This case reinstates that even procedural missteps can vitiate otherwise lawful enforcement actions.
Summary of Referred Cases
| Name | Citation | Summary | Verdict |
| No specific external cases referred in judgment | – | – | – |




