Case Title: Gurudas Mallik Thakur & Dinesh Kumar Raghav v. Commissioner of Central Goods & Service Tax & Anr.
Court: High Court of Delhi
Petition No.: W.P.(C) 5083/2025 & W.P.(C) 5133/2025
Date of Judgement: 23rd April, 2025
Category: Input Tax Credit & Director’s Liability
Relevant Sections: Section 74, Section 50, Section 83, Section 107, Section 122(1), Section 122(1A), Section 125 of the CGST Act, 2017; corresponding provisions of DGST & IGST Acts.
Facts of the Case
(Ref: Paras 3–10)
-
Petitioners were directors of M/s Planman HR Pvt. Ltd., engaged in manpower recruitment.
-
Department alleged inadmissible ITC of ₹22.41 crore and GST short payment of ₹40.61 crore.
-
Company failed to file GSTR-1 beyond Feb 2019 and GSTR-3B beyond Dec 2018.
-
SCN dated 21.04.2023 led to Order-in-Original dated 23.01.2025 confirming demands under Section 74.
-
Penalties were also imposed on the company, its promoter (Arindam Chaudhary), CEO (Varun Khanna), and the two petitioner-directors under Sections 122(1A) & 125.
Questions in Consideration
(Ref: Paras 11–16, 18–20)
-
Whether directors who are not “taxable persons” can still be penalised under Section 122(1A) of the CGST Act?
-
Whether the writ petition is maintainable, or the petitioners must pursue appellate remedies under Section 107?
-
Whether penalties imposed after 01.01.2021 (when Section 122(1A) came into force) can apply to directors who resigned earlier?
Observations of the Court
(Ref: Paras 19–33)
-
Petitioners admittedly were directors; their precise role and benefit derived must be factually ascertained by the Appellate Authority, not in writ jurisdiction.
-
Section 107 permits “any person” (not only taxable persons) to appeal.
-
Definition of “person” under Section 2(84) is wide, covering individuals including directors.
-
Section 122(1) applies to taxable persons, but Section 122(1A) targets “any person” who retains benefit of fraudulent transactions.
-
Such provisions exist to fix responsibility where companies (being artificial entities) act through individuals.
-
Petitioners’ claim that they resigned before 01.01.2021 is a factual defence for appeal.
Judgement of the Court
(Ref: Paras 31–44)
-
Writ petitions disposed of; remedy lies in filing appeal under Section 107.
-
Department directed to communicate mechanism within 2 weeks to enable directors (non-taxable persons) to file appeal on portal or manually.
-
Appeal to be filed within 30 days thereafter and not dismissed on limitation grounds.
-
Appellate Authority to decide on merits, including timing of resignation vis-à-vis Section 122(1A).
Between Fine Lines
-
Directors can be penalised under Section 122(1A) even if not taxable persons.
-
Appeal is open to any person penalised, not just companies.
-
Factual responsibility (who controlled the company/benefitted) must be tested in appeal.
-
Non-taxable persons (directors) must be given mechanism to appeal.
-
Writ not maintainable; appellate route is proper remedy.
Summary of Referred Cases
| Case | Citation | Summary | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| Amit Manilal Haria v. JC CGST & CE | WP 5001/2025 (Bombay HC) | CFO held employee, not director; interim relief granted. | Interim relief; not binding precedent. |
| Shantanu Sanjay Hundekari v. UOI | (2024) 132 GSTR 346 (Bom HC), upheld in SLP (C) 55427/2024 (SC) | Employee (not director) wrongly fastened with ₹3731 crore liability. | SC upheld interim relief; left law open. |
| Bharat Parihar v. State of Maharashtra | 2023 SCC Online Bom 1310 | Held “any person” in Sec 122(1A) includes non-taxable persons; jurisdiction extends even outside State. | Directors/employees can be proceeded against. |
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”



