Home Case Laws Directors Can Be Penalised Under Section 122(1A) – Delhi HC Clarifies

Directors Can Be Penalised Under Section 122(1A) – Delhi HC Clarifies

0
473

Case Title: Gurudas Mallik Thakur & Dinesh Kumar Raghav v. Commissioner of Central Goods & Service Tax & Anr.
Court: High Court of Delhi
Petition No.: W.P.(C) 5083/2025 & W.P.(C) 5133/2025
Date of Judgement: 23rd April, 2025
Category: Input Tax Credit & Director’s Liability
Relevant Sections: Section 74, Section 50, Section 83, Section 107, Section 122(1), Section 122(1A), Section 125 of the CGST Act, 2017; corresponding provisions of DGST & IGST Acts.


Facts of the Case

(Ref: Paras 3–10)

  • Petitioners were directors of M/s Planman HR Pvt. Ltd., engaged in manpower recruitment.

  • Department alleged inadmissible ITC of ₹22.41 crore and GST short payment of ₹40.61 crore.

  • Company failed to file GSTR-1 beyond Feb 2019 and GSTR-3B beyond Dec 2018.

  • SCN dated 21.04.2023 led to Order-in-Original dated 23.01.2025 confirming demands under Section 74.

  • Penalties were also imposed on the company, its promoter (Arindam Chaudhary), CEO (Varun Khanna), and the two petitioner-directors under Sections 122(1A) & 125.


Questions in Consideration

(Ref: Paras 11–16, 18–20)

  1. Whether directors who are not “taxable persons” can still be penalised under Section 122(1A) of the CGST Act?

  2. Whether the writ petition is maintainable, or the petitioners must pursue appellate remedies under Section 107?

  3. Whether penalties imposed after 01.01.2021 (when Section 122(1A) came into force) can apply to directors who resigned earlier?


Observations of the Court

(Ref: Paras 19–33)

  • Petitioners admittedly were directors; their precise role and benefit derived must be factually ascertained by the Appellate Authority, not in writ jurisdiction.

  • Section 107 permits “any person” (not only taxable persons) to appeal.

  • Definition of “person” under Section 2(84) is wide, covering individuals including directors.

  • Section 122(1) applies to taxable persons, but Section 122(1A) targets “any person” who retains benefit of fraudulent transactions.

  • Such provisions exist to fix responsibility where companies (being artificial entities) act through individuals.

  • Petitioners’ claim that they resigned before 01.01.2021 is a factual defence for appeal.


Judgement of the Court

(Ref: Paras 31–44)

  • Writ petitions disposed of; remedy lies in filing appeal under Section 107.

  • Department directed to communicate mechanism within 2 weeks to enable directors (non-taxable persons) to file appeal on portal or manually.

  • Appeal to be filed within 30 days thereafter and not dismissed on limitation grounds.

  • Appellate Authority to decide on merits, including timing of resignation vis-à-vis Section 122(1A).


Between Fine Lines

  • Directors can be penalised under Section 122(1A) even if not taxable persons.

  • Appeal is open to any person penalised, not just companies.

  • Factual responsibility (who controlled the company/benefitted) must be tested in appeal.

  • Non-taxable persons (directors) must be given mechanism to appeal.

  • Writ not maintainable; appellate route is proper remedy.


Summary of Referred Cases

Case Citation Summary Verdict
Amit Manilal Haria v. JC CGST & CE WP 5001/2025 (Bombay HC) CFO held employee, not director; interim relief granted. Interim relief; not binding precedent.
Shantanu Sanjay Hundekari v. UOI (2024) 132 GSTR 346 (Bom HC), upheld in SLP (C) 55427/2024 (SC) Employee (not director) wrongly fastened with ₹3731 crore liability. SC upheld interim relief; left law open.
Bharat Parihar v. State of Maharashtra 2023 SCC Online Bom 1310 Held “any person” in Sec 122(1A) includes non-taxable persons; jurisdiction extends even outside State. Directors/employees can be proceeded against.

 

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY