Home Case Laws Ex Parte GST Demand Set Aside Due to Improper Notice Service

Ex Parte GST Demand Set Aside Due to Improper Notice Service

0
274

Case Title: M/s Som Fragrances Private Limited v. State of U.P. and 2 Others
Court: High Court of Judicature at Allahabad
Petition No.: Writ Tax No. 1987 of 2025
Category: Natural Justice – Ex Parte Order – GST Demand
Date of Judgement: 16.05.2025
Relevant Sections: Section 73 of CGST Act, 2017
Hon’ble Judge: Justice Ajit Kumar


Facts of the Case (Para2–4):

  1. The petitioner, M/s Som Fragrances Pvt. Ltd., engaged in trading unserviceable store goods, challenged the order dated 26.03.2025 passed by the first appellate authority confirming a demand of tax, interest and penalty by the Assessing Officer under Section 73 (Para 2).

  2. The petitioner claimed that the reminder show cause notice was neither received physically nor visible on the GST portal under “view additional notices and orders” tab. The final order dated 30.12.2023 was known only in February 2025 when it was uploaded online (Para 3).

  3. Consequently, the petitioner missed the opportunity to respond to the SCN and also failed to file a timely appeal, which the appellate authority dismissed as time-barred (Para 4).


Questions in Consideration (Para 4):

  1. Whether the service of reminder SCN through the GST portal was proper and whether the petitioner was denied an opportunity of hearing?

  2. Whether the appellate authority erred in dismissing the appeal solely on limitation when the delay was due to lack of notice?


Observations of the Court (Para 5–9):

  1. The Court relied on previous judgments including Ola Fleet Technologies Pvt. Ltd. (Writ Tax No. 855 of 2024), which held that if notices are not visible in the portal tab, it results in denial of natural justice (Para 5–6).

  2. The principle that “no one should be condemned unheard” was emphasized, and courts consistently held that non-service of notice violates the purpose of Section 73 (Para 8).

  3. The Court followed the precedent in Akriti Food Industry LLP v. State of U.P. (Writ Tax No. 2070 of 2024) where a similar ex parte order was quashed (Para 9).


Judgement of the Court (Para10–12):

  1. The order dated 30.12.2023 passed by the Assessing Officer was treated as a show cause notice under Section 73 (Para10).

  2. The petitioner was permitted to file objections and documents within 8 weeks from the date of judgment, and a fresh decision would be taken within 4 weeks thereafter after providing an opportunity of hearing (Para 11).

  3. The writ petition was disposed of with these directions (Para12).


Between Fine Lines:

  • If a taxpayer is unaware of SCN due to technical or procedural lapse (like non-display on the portal), ex parte orders can be challenged.

  • Natural justice requires proper service of notice and opportunity to respond before confirming tax liability.

  • Courts are inclined to set aside orders passed without due process.

  • Section 73 notices must be communicated effectively, not merely uploaded.

  • Limitation for appeals may be relaxed if delay results from lack of notice.


Summary of Referred Cases:

Case Name Citation Summary Verdict
Ola Fleet Technologies Pvt. Ltd. v. State of U.P. Writ Tax No. 855 of 2024 Order set aside due to non-visibility of SCN on GST portal; fresh opportunity granted Remanded for fresh decision
Shyam Roshan Transport v. State of U.P. Writ Tax No. 1756 of 2024 Reinforced that service of SCN is necessary before passing order under Section 73 Order quashed and remitted back
Atul Agrawal v. State of U.P. Writ Tax No. 1585 of 2024 Ex parte order under GST set aside; opportunity to reply and hearing ordered Case restored for reconsideration
Akriti Food Industry LLP v. State of U.P. Writ Tax No. 2070 of 2024 Similar facts; order quashed for want of notice and opportunity of hearing Impugned order set aside

 

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY