Home Case Laws Excess Demand Beyond SCN Set Aside; Matter Remanded for Fresh Adjudication

Excess Demand Beyond SCN Set Aside; Matter Remanded for Fresh Adjudication

0
331

Case Title: M/s. NTT India Private Limited vs. Joint Commissioner (ST), Intelligence-I & Ors.
Court: High Court of Judicature at Madras
Petition Number: W.P. No.1323 of 2025
Category of Dispute: Natural Justice / Assessment Order
Date of Judgment: 27.01.2025
Relevant Section: Section 75(7), Section 107, and Section 54 of the CGST / TNGST Act, 2017


Facts of the Case (Relevant Para: 2)

The Petitioner, M/s. NTT India Pvt. Ltd., challenged an order passed in Form GST DRC-07 dated 16.08.2024, contending that the demand of ₹137 Crores was excessive and contrary to the show cause notice (SCN) issued in Form DRC-01, which had originally proposed a tax demand of ₹54.50 Crores across 25 issues. After submitting detailed replies to the SCN, nearly ₹51 Crores worth of issues were allegedly dropped. Yet, the final order created a fresh and escalated demand, violating principles of natural justice and the statutory limit under Section 75(7).


Questions in Consideration (Relevant Para: 2-3)

  1. Whether the impugned order in Form GST DRC-07 could demand tax in excess of what was proposed in the SCN under DRC-01?

  2. Whether such a demand is violative of Section 75(7) of the CGST Act?

  3. Whether the impugned order can be treated as a fresh SCN to allow de novo adjudication?


Observations of the Court (Relevant Para: 3-5)

  • The Court noted that the increase in demand from ₹54.50 Crores to ₹137 Crores without proper quantification or notification in the SCN is a violation of Section 75(7), which mandates that the final order cannot travel beyond the amounts specified in the notice.

  • The Revenue’s justification that not all issues were quantified in the SCN was held insufficient to bypass the statutory protection.

  • Both parties agreed to a mediated remedy: the Court suggested and the parties consented to remit the matter back for fresh consideration on payment of ₹2 Crores as a condition.


Judgment of the Court (Relevant Para: 5-6)

  • The High Court set aside the impugned assessment order dated 16.08.2024.

  • The matter was remanded to the Assessing Officer for de novo adjudication, treating the earlier assessment order as a fresh SCN.

  • The Petitioner was directed to:

    • Deposit ₹2 Crores within three weeks.

    • Submit objections along with documents within four weeks.

  • In case of default in deposit or filing objections, the original order shall revive.


🧾 Between Fine Lines

  1. An assessment order demanding tax beyond what is stated in the show cause notice is not legally sustainable.

  2. The High Court re-emphasized the binding nature of Section 75(7), protecting taxpayers from surprise demands.

  3. Both parties accepted remand for reconsideration, subject to a ₹2 Crore deposit.

  4. The impugned order will now act as a fresh SCN, providing the taxpayer an opportunity to respond.

  5. Procedural fairness and statutory compliance were the decisive factors.


📚 Summary of Referred Cases

Name of Case Citation Summary Verdict
None referred — No precedents were specifically cited in the judgment —

 

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY