Case Details
| Particulars | Details |
|---|---|
| Case | JCIT(OSD), Range-10 v. Gem Agrofoods Pvt. Ltd. |
| Forum | Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Delhi Bench “E” |
| Coram | Shri Satbeer Singh Godara, Judicial Member and Shri M. Balaganesh, Accountant Member |
| Appeal | ITA No. 1227/Del/2025 |
| Cross-Objection | CO No. 50/Del/2026 |
| Assessment Year | 2014-15 |
| Date of Hearing | 2 July 2026 |
| Date of Decision | 21 August 2026 |
| Outcome | Revenue’s appeal dismissed; assessee’s cross-objection allowed |
| Decision in favour of | Assessee |
Headnote
Income Tax – Sections 28(iv), 28(va), 115JB and 14A – Exclusivity fee received upon failure of a proposed joint venture – Restriction related only to negotiations for the transfer of shares and not to the carrying on of any business activity – Monetary receipt outside the scope of Section 28(iv), as applicable to Assessment Year 2014-15 – Section 28(va) inapplicable in the absence of any restraint on business – Receipt held to be capital in nature – No addition permissible under the normal provisions or while computing book profit under Section 115JB – Section 14A disallowance also deleted where no exempt income was earned.
Background
Gem Agrofoods Pvt. Ltd., formerly known as Gem Engineering Private Limited, was engaged primarily in trading barley and related products. It held 60% of the equity shares in Malt Company India Private Limited (“MCIL”), which manufactured malt and malt extracts.
A French malt manufacturer, Malteries Soufflet S.A.S., approached the promoters of the assessee for establishing a proposed joint venture in the malt business. A Non-Disclosure Agreement was executed on 13 September 2009, followed by a Memorandum of Understanding dated 18 November 2010.
The MOU contained an exclusivity arrangement under which the assessee and the Jain family were restricted from negotiating with third parties regarding the sale, transfer or issuance of shares connected with the proposed joint venture. Despite negotiations continuing for nearly four years, the proposed joint venture did not materialise.
The assessee consequently received an aggregate exclusivity fee of ₹12,74,15,684, comprising ₹7,17,68,320 received during the relevant year and ₹5,56,47,364 received in the following assessment year. The amount was credited to the capital reserve and treated as a capital receipt.
Assessment Proceedings
The Assessing Officer treated the entire exclusivity fee as a revenue receipt taxable under Sections 28(iv) and 28(va) of the Income-tax Act, 1961. The Assessing Officer also added the amount while computing book profit under Section 115JB.
The Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) deleted the addition after finding that the proposed transaction concerned the transfer of shares, which constituted a capital asset. The assessee had not agreed to discontinue or restrict any of its business activities.
The Revenue challenged this finding before the ITAT.
Issues Before the Tribunal
The principal issues were whether:
- The exclusivity fee of ₹12,74,15,684 was a taxable revenue receipt or a capital receipt;
- The amount could be taxed under Section 28(iv) or Section 28(va);
- The amount could be included in book profit under Section 115JB; and
- A disallowance under Section 14A could be sustained when the assessee had not earned any exempt income.
ITAT’s Findings
Section 28(iv) Not Applicable to Cash Receipt
The Tribunal observed that, under the provisions applicable to Assessment Year 2014-15, Section 28(iv) covered benefits or perquisites arising from business that were received in a form other than money.
Since the exclusivity fee was received in cash, it fell outside the scope of Section 28(iv). The Tribunal relied upon the Supreme Court’s decision in CIT v. Mahindra and Mahindra Ltd., 404 ITR 1, which held that a monetary receipt could not be taxed under the then-existing Section 28(iv).
No Restriction on Business Activity Under Section 28(va)
Section 28(va) applies where an amount is received under an agreement for not carrying out an activity relating to a business.
The ITAT found that the assessee’s commitment was confined to refraining from negotiating the sale or transfer of shares with third parties during the exclusivity period. It was not prevented from carrying on its existing business activities.
Accordingly, the essential condition for invoking Section 28(va) was not satisfied.
Exclusivity Fee Was a Capital Receipt
The proposed transaction related to the transfer of shares held by the assessee in MCIL. Since the shares constituted a capital asset, the compensation received following the failure of the proposed transaction retained a capital character.
The Tribunal distinguished the Supreme Court’s decision in Gillanders Arbuthnot & Co. Ltd. v. CIT, 53 ITR 283, noting that the compensation in that case arose from the termination of an agency in the ordinary course of business. In the present case, the payment arose from an unsuccessful capital transaction involving the proposed transfer of shares.
The ITAT therefore upheld the finding that the exclusivity fee was a capital receipt and had been correctly credited to the capital reserve.
No Addition Under Section 115JB
As the exclusivity fee was a capital receipt, the Tribunal held that it could not be brought to tax either under the normal provisions of the Act or while computing book profit under Section 115JB.
Section 14A Disallowance Deleted
In its cross-objection, the assessee challenged the disallowance sustained under Section 14A.
The Tribunal noted that the assessee had not earned any exempt income during the relevant assessment year. It further held that the Explanation inserted in Section 14A by the Finance Act, 2022 applies prospectively from Assessment Year 2022-23 and could not be applied to Assessment Year 2014-15.
Relying on PCIT v. ERA Infrastructure India Ltd., 448 ITR 674 (Delhi), the ITAT deleted the Section 14A disallowance.
Decision
The ITAT upheld the order deleting the addition of ₹12,74,15,684. It held that the exclusivity fee received for refraining from negotiating the transfer of shares with third parties was a capital receipt and was not taxable under Sections 28(iv) or 28(va), or as part of book profit under Section 115JB.
The Revenue’s appeal was dismissed, while the assessee’s cross-objection challenging the Section 14A disallowance was allowed.
Key Takeaway
Compensation received under an exclusivity arrangement connected with a proposed transfer of shares may constitute a capital receipt where the agreement does not restrain the recipient from carrying on its business. Further, for years preceding Assessment Year 2022-23, a Section 14A disallowance cannot ordinarily be sustained in the absence of exempt income.




