Case Title: KBVTIL Kampa Bhai Vocational Training Institute Ltd. v. State of Odisha
Court: High Court of Orissa
Petition No.: W.P. (C) No. 17635 of 2021
Category of Dispute: Tender Disqualification / Quoting Tax in Bid
Date of Judgement: June 11, 2021
Relevant Section: Section 170 of the Central Goods and Services Tax (CGST) Act, 2017
Facts of the Case
- The petitioner, Kampa Bhai Vocational Training Institute Ltd., challenged the rejection of its bid by the Principal Chief Conservator of Forests, Kendu Leaves, Odisha, who awarded the contract to the second-highest bidder, Kalinga Warriors Security Services
(Para 2). - The reason for rejection was a discrepancy in the quoted GST component. The petitioner quoted ₹1675 as GST, while the calculated 18% GST on ₹9307.01 should be ₹1657.26. This resulted in a total quoted figure of ₹10,982.01 instead of ₹10,982.27, causing alleged “suppression of material fact”. (para 3)
Questions in Consideration
- Whether the rounding off of tax figures by the petitioner at the time of bid quoting was permissible under Section 170 of the CGST Act?
(Para 4) - Whether the Tender Inviting Authority was justified in rejecting the bid due to this minor discrepancy in GST computation?
(Para 3, 5)
Observation of the Court
- The Court held that Section 170 of the CGST Act, 2017 pertains to rounding off payable tax amounts during filing of returns or payment stages, and not to be used while quoting bid prices during tender submission (Para 6).
- Therefore, the reliance on Section 170 for justifying the rounded-off bid figure at the submission stage was deemed misconceived by the Court (para 6)
Judgement of the Court
- The Court found no infirmity in the Tender Inviting Authority’s decision to reject the petitioner’s bid on the ground of incorrect GST computation
- The writ petition was dismissed accordingly
(Para 7)
Between Fine Lines
- Rounding off of tax under Section 170 CGST Act is meant for final tax payments, not for quoting bid prices.
- Even a minor computational error in tax during tender submission can lead to bid rejection.
- Authorities are justified in applying strict compliance norms in government tenders.
- The scope of judicial interference in bid evaluation is limited unless there is arbitrariness.
- Technical compliance in bid documents is critical and can override the lowest bid advantage.
Summary of Referred Cases
No case laws were cited or referred to by either side in the judgement.




