Home Updates Delhi High Court: Sections 67 and 74A of CGST Act Operate in...

Delhi High Court: Sections 67 and 74A of CGST Act Operate in Distinct Fields

0
118

The Delhi High Court, in M/s. Goel Metal v. Union of India & Ors., considered a writ petition raising questions concerning seizure and release of goods under Section 67(6) of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017, the determination mechanism under Section 74A, and subsequent confiscation proceedings under Section 130. The order was passed on 5 August 2026 by a Division Bench comprising Justice Anil Kshetrapal and Justice Shail Jain.

The petitioner had challenged, among other things, the operation and constitutional validity of Section 67(6) of the CGST Act insofar as it provides for provisional release of seized goods. It contended that where the applicable tax, interest and penalty had already been discharged in terms of Section 74A(9), the seizure ought to stand finally vacated rather than remain subject merely to provisional release. The petitioner also questioned Rule 140 of the CGST Rules for allegedly not providing a mechanism for absolute release of seized goods in such circumstances.

The writ petition further challenged a show cause notice dated 10 June 2026 issued under Section 130 of the CGST Act. The petitioner sought to contend that confiscation proceedings and proposed penalty proceedings under Section 122 could not continue after proceedings had allegedly concluded under Section 74A(9). It also questioned the seizure of unaccounted goods made under Section 67(2).

Delhi High Court’s Observation on Sections 67 and 74A

The Court noted that Section 67 deals with powers of inspection, search and seizure, while Section 74A concerns determination of tax that has not been paid, has been short-paid or erroneously refunded, or where input tax credit has been wrongly availed or utilised. Significantly, the Court observed that the two provisions operate in different and distinct fields.

The Court also observed that a person challenging the constitutional validity of a statutory provision must establish that the provision infringes a constitutional mandate. The order does not record any declaration striking down Section 67(6) or Rule 140 of the CGST Rules.

Challenge to Confiscation Show Cause Notice

The impugned show cause notice alleged that the petitioner had supplied copper scrap to M/s WMIPL on the basis of fraudulent input tax credit and that fake firms had been registered with a view to defraud the revenue. Instead of adjudicating these factual allegations in the writ proceedings, the High Court permitted the petitioner, if so advised, to submit an appropriate reply to the show cause notice and seek dropping of the proceedings.

Accordingly, the writ petition was disposed of with the aforesaid observations, together with the pending applications. The Court therefore did not accept the writ petition as a basis for terminating the show cause proceedings at that stage, leaving it open to the petitioner to raise its objections before the competent authority through its reply.

Key Legal Takeaway

The order is relevant to GST search and seizure disputes because the Delhi High Court has expressly recognised the distinct statutory fields occupied by Section 67 and Section 74A of the CGST Act. Payment or determination issues under Section 74A do not, merely by their nature, make the statutory scheme governing search, seizure and release under Section 67 identical or interchangeable. Further, where confiscation allegations are contained in a show cause notice, the affected taxpayer may be required to first place its objections before the adjudicating authority rather than seek premature termination of the proceedings through writ jurisdiction.

Download

LEAVE A REPLY