Home Case Laws Goods and Vehicle were released in case of clerical/typographical mistake in E-way...

Goods and Vehicle were released in case of clerical/typographical mistake in E-way bill (Circular no. 64/38/2018 – GST, dated 14-9-2018)

0
679

Case Title: Sabitha Riyaz v. Union of India

Court: High Court of Kerala

Petition Number: WP(C) No. 34874 of 2018

Category of Dispute: E-Way Bill, Detention of Goods

Date of Judgement: 31 October 2018

Relevant Provisions: Rule 138(9) of CGST Rules, Circular No. 64/38/2018-GST dated 14.09.2018

 

Facts of the Case

  1. The petitioner, Sabitha Riyaz, a trader from Kerala, transported natural rubber to Uttarakhand after generating an e-way bill with all required documents (¶1).
  2. The consignment was intercepted and detained by the State Tax Officer, Uttarakhand (Respondent 11), due to an error in the e-way bill where the distance was shown as 280 km instead of 2800 km (¶1).
  3. The petitioner contended it was a typographical error, only noticed upon interception, and referred to Rule 138(9), which allows rectification within 24 hours— a period which had lapsed (¶1-2).
  4. The Standing Counsel for the respondents admitted the mistake was genuine but argued there was no legal provision allowing correction or issuance of a certificate by Kerala authorities (¶3).
  5. The petitioner urged for urgent relief as natural rubber has a short shelf life and the delay would render it unusable (¶5).

 

Question(s) in Consideration

  1. Whether a typographical error in the e-way bill regarding distance can be treated as a minor mistake under GST law.
  2. Whether detention of goods for such minor discrepancies is justified when it causes loss of perishable goods.
  3. Whether relief can be granted under Circular No. 64/38/2018-GST dated 14.09.2018 for clerical errors.

(Reference: ¶2, ¶5, ¶6)

 

Observation of the Court

  1. The Court acknowledged that the discrepancy (280 km instead of 2800 km) was a simple typographical mistake— omission of a single zero (¶6).
  2. It referred to the CBIC Circular No. 64/38/2018-GST, which provides guidance against harsh action for minor discrepancies in e-way bills (¶6).
  3. The Court emphasized that the error was minor, genuine, and verifiable, hence not warranting punitive detention of goods (¶6).

 

Judgement of the Court

  1. The Court directed the 11th respondent (State Tax Officer, Uttarakhand) to consider the petitioner’s case for release of goods under the above-mentioned Circular (¶6).
  2. The writ petition was accordingly disposed of with instructions to act expeditiously to prevent further loss (¶6).

Between Fine Lines

  • A mere typographical error in an e-way bill (like a missing digit in distance) does not justify detention of goods.
  • Perishable goods require urgent handling; GST enforcement should be sensitive to such aspects.
  • Rule 138(9) offers limited time for correction, but genuine errors can be addressed through administrative circulars.
  • Circular No. 64/38/2018-GST serves as a safeguard against unnecessary hardship due to minor clerical errors.
  • The judiciary recognizes administrative fairness and promotes corrective over punitive action in GST compliance.

 

Summary of Referred Cases

Name of Case Citation Summary Verdict
Circular No. 64/38/2018-GST CBIC Circular, dated 14.09.2018 Issued to prevent undue detention of goods for minor errors in documents during transportation Applied in favor of the petitioner to grant release of detained goods

 

LEAVE A REPLY