Case Title: Tvl. Sri Balaji Traders v. Deputy Commercial Tax Officer, Chidambaram – I, Cuddalore
Court: Madras High Court
Petition No.: W.P. No. 5539 of 2025 with W.M.P. Nos. 6103 & 6104 of 2025
Date of Judgment: 24 February 2025
Category: Assessment – Violation of Natural Justice / Mode of Service of Notice
Relevant Section: Section 169, CGST Act, 2017
Facts (Paras 2–6)
The petitioner, Tvl. Sri Balaji Traders, challenged the assessment order dated 24.08.2024 and subsequent bank attachment under Form DRC-13 dated 05.02.2025. The petitioner contended that the show cause notice (SCN) in Form DRC-01 and three subsequent reminders were uploaded on the GST portal under the “View Additional Notices/Orders” tab instead of the usual “View Notices/Orders” tab. Being an illiterate person with limited access to technology, the petitioner was unaware of these uploads and did not respond. The order was passed ex parte, followed by recovery action.
The respondent argued that notices were validly served as per Section 169(d) of the CGST Act (via online portal) and that ignorance of the law cannot be an excuse. It was also contended that taxpayers should engage GST practitioners to monitor the portal regularly.
Questions before the Court (Para 7)
-
Whether the assessment order passed ex parte violated principles of natural justice?
-
Whether uploading notices in the GST portal under “Additional Notices/Orders” constitutes valid service under Section 169 of the CGST Act, 2017?
Observations (Paras 7–9.9)
The Court noted the increasing trend of taxpayers approaching courts due to unnoticed notices uploaded in portal tabs other than the usual “Notices/Orders” section.
Referring to Section 169, the Court clarified that the law provides multiple modes of service — physical delivery, RPAD, email, publication, and upload on the common portal. While the online mode is legally recognized, the Department must ensure effective service in a manner that ensures the assessee actually receives notice.
The Court emphasized that:
-
Digital communication is a modern tool but not a substitute for fair hearing.
-
Illiterate and small taxpayers dependent on consultants may not regularly check online portals.
-
Repeated uploads under different tabs do not fulfill natural justice when the taxpayer is unaware.
-
The Department must switch to an alternate mode such as Registered Post Acknowledgment Due (RPAD) if online service yields no response.
Thus, merely uploading notices under “Additional Notices/Orders” cannot be treated as valid service.
Judgment (Paras 9.10–10)
The Court held the assessment order void for violation of natural justice and set it aside. Directions issued:
-
The matter was remanded for fresh consideration.
-
The petitioner must file a reply with documents within three weeks.
-
The respondent must issue a 14-day notice and provide a personal hearing.
-
The bank attachment under Form DRC-13 was ordered to be lifted.
-
The Court suggested the Department prefer RPAD service where online service fails, stating that technological advancement cannot replace fair opportunity.
Summary of Cases Referred
| Case / Reference | Principle / Verdict |
|---|---|
| Section 169, CGST Act | Specifies multiple valid modes of service – online, RPAD, email, courier, etc.; ensures opportunity of being heard. |
| Ignorantia juris non excusat | Ignorance of law is not an excuse but fairness in communication is essential. |
| Court’s observation in similar petitions | Uploading notices in unusual tabs not accessible to taxpayers amounts to ineffective service. |
Between Fine Lines
For trade and tax practitioners, this ruling highlights that service of notice must be effective, not merely technical. Uploading notices in obscure sections of the GST portal cannot substitute actual communication, especially for small or technologically unskilled taxpayers. Departments should adopt RPAD or direct delivery if no online acknowledgment is received. This decision sets a precedent for quashing assessments passed without ensuring proper service under Section 169.
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”




