Agarwal Foundries Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India
High Court of Telangana
Writ Petition No. 28268 of 2019
Section: 67 of the CGST Act, 2017 / TSGST Act, 2017
Category: Search & Seizure – Abuse of Powers
Date of Judgement: 06.11.2020
Facts of the Case [Paras 2–19]
- Agarwal Foundries Pvt. Ltd., a steel manufacturer registered under CGST, was subjected to simultaneous raids on its business premises and the residence of its director on 11.12.2019 by officers of the Directorate General of GST Intelligence (DGGI), New Delhi.
- The company and its director alleged that officers used physical violence during interrogation, abused and assaulted employees and family members (Paras 6–8), and coerced them into signing statements without verification (Para 12).
- The 3rd petitioner was allegedly injured and treated for blunt trauma, evidenced by a medical certificate (Para 9). A call was made to local police (Para 10), but the FIR was lodged later by DGGI officers against the petitioners (Para 15).
- Summons were issued post-midnight (12.12.2019 at 00:30 hrs), which was alleged to be arbitrary (Para 13).
- Petitioners filed the writ seeking transfer of investigation and protection from coercion.
Question(s) in Consideration
- Whether officers under CGST Act can use violence or coercion during search and interrogation proceedings?
- Whether the petitioners are entitled to safeguards including presence of an advocate during questioning and relief from night-time interrogations?
- Whether the investigation should be transferred from the officer allegedly involved in violence?
Observation of Court [Paras 60–107]
- The Court observed prima facie evidence suggesting physical violence (medical records, police call logs) could not be ignored [Paras 65–71].
- Emphasized that protection under Article 21 prohibits torture and coercion by State actors; cited D.K. Basu v. State of W.B. [Paras 76–78].
- Disapproved interrogation at midnight (summons at 00:30 hrs) as arbitrary and violative of liberty [Paras 83–87, 89].
- Held that right to legal counsel in visible (but non-audible) range during interrogation may be permitted based on earlier SC and HC decisions [Paras 95–100].
- Rejected respondents’ argument that physical violence was justified or necessary; found the officer in question (Respondent No. 5) should be excluded from further enquiry [Para 94].
- Given the pandemic situation and cost concerns, directed that majority of the inquiry be conducted at Hyderabad rather than New Delhi [Paras 104–107].
Judgement of the Court [Para 108]
- The writ petition was allowed with the following directions:
- (a) No acts of violence/torture shall be used by GST officers against petitioners.
- (b) The officer involved in alleged violence (Respondent No. 5) shall not be part of the ongoing enquiry.
- (c) Interrogations shall be conducted between 10:30 a.m. and 5:00 p.m. on weekdays, in visible range of a legal counsel (non-hearing).
- (d) Petitioners 2 to 4 may be called to New Delhi only once, others to be questioned in Hyderabad.
- (e) Officers to strictly follow CGST Act provisions in search and enquiry.
Between Fine Lines
- GST officers cannot resort to coercion or violence during search and seizure.
- Petitioners are entitled to presence of a legal counsel during interrogation within visual range.
- Night-time interrogation was found unacceptable and violative of fundamental rights.
- Investigation partially redirected to Hyderabad to avoid undue burden and health risk.
- Officers found potentially involved in misconduct were removed from the ongoing investigation.
Summary of Referred Cases
| Case Name | Citation | Summary | Verdict |
| D.K. Basu v. State of W.B. | [1997] 1 SCC 416 | Landmark case establishing guidelines against custodial torture by state authorities. | Followed – No violence allowed. |
| P.V. Ramana Reddy v. Union of India | [2019] 104 taxmann.com 407 | Summoning power under Section 70 is judicial, not criminal; arrest power must follow procedure. | Followed with limited application. |
| Poolpandi v. Supdt., Central Excise | AIR 1992 SC 1795 | Denied presence of counsel during interrogation. | Distinguished. |
| Senior Intelligence Officer v. J.K. Samra | [2011] 12 SCC 362 | Allowed presence of advocate in visible but non-hearing range during interrogation. | Followed. |
| Jignesh Kishorbhai Bhajiawala v. State | 2017 Crl. L.J. 1760 | Gujarat HC allowed visible range legal presence during interrogation in PMLA matters. | Followed. |
| Birendra Kumar Pandey v. Union of India | W.P. (Crl.) No. 28 of 2012 | SC permitted lawyer’s presence within visible range; referenced D.K. Basu. | Followed. |
| Sudhir Kumar Agarwal v. DGGI | W.P. (Crl.) No. 2686 of 2019 | Delhi HC case denying lawyer presence; relied by respondents. | Not followed. |
| Sudhir Gulati v. Union of India | 1998 taxmann.com 1219 (Delhi) | On procedural limits of interrogation. | Distinguished. |




