Case Details
-
Court: High Court of Judicature at Allahabad
-
Case Number: Writ Tax No. 1376 of 2024
-
Petitioner: M/s Dee Control and Electric Private Ltd.
-
Respondent: Additional Commissioner Grade-2 and Another
-
Date of Judgment: 07.01.2025
-
Relevant Sections: Section 130, Section 35(6), Sections 73 & 74 of CGST/UPGST Act, 2017; Rule 122 of UPGST Rules, 2017
-
Category: Confiscation of goods / Wrongful invocation of Section 130
Facts (Paras 2–7)
The petitioner, engaged in manufacturing and trading transformers and electric parts for government supply, was subjected to a survey under Section 67 of the UPGST Act on 25.10.2018 by the Special Investigation Branch. Based on eye estimation, excess stock was alleged. Proceedings were then initiated under Section 130 of the UPGST Act for confiscation. The petitioner argued that Section 130 could not be applied against a registered dealer for excess stock, and that the proper course was assessment under Section 35(6) read with Sections 73 or 74. Reliance was placed on S/S Dinesh Kumar Pradeep Kumar v. Addl. Commissioner Grade-2 (Writ Tax No. 1082 of 2022, decided 25.07.2024).
Questions Before the Court (Paras 3, 8–9)
-
Whether excess stock detected during survey can be a ground for initiating confiscation under Section 130.
-
Whether tax liability for unaccounted goods is to be determined under Section 73 or 74 instead.
-
Whether estimation of stock on eye estimation can be the basis of tax and penalty.
Observations (Paras 8–13)
The Court reiterated its earlier rulings in Metenere Ltd., Shree Om Steels, and Maa Mahamaya Alloys Pvt. Ltd., where it was held that:
-
Section 9 is the charging section; tax liability arises only at the point of supply (Para 22).
-
Section 35(6) treats unaccounted goods as “deemed supply,” but tax must be determined under Section 73/74 (Paras 24–27).
-
Section 130 cannot be used for determination of tax on excess stock.
-
Confiscation under Section 130(1)(ii) or (iv) requires an intent to evade tax, which was absent here.
-
Eye estimation cannot be the sole basis for valuation (Maa Mahamaya Alloys, Para 11–13).
Thus, the initiation of proceedings under Section 130 against a registered dealer for excess stock was contrary to law.
Judgment (Paras 10–11)
The High Court quashed the orders dated 27.02.2024, 05.04.2019, and notice dated 15.12.2018, holding that Section 130 proceedings were unsustainable. The writ petition was allowed.
Case Law References in Judgment
| Case Name | Citation/Case No. | Verdict/Ratio |
|---|---|---|
| S/S Dinesh Kumar Pradeep Kumar v. Addl. Commissioner Grade-2 | Writ Tax No. 1082 of 2022, decided 25.07.2024 | Held that excess stock cannot be subjected to Section 130; must be assessed under Sec. 73/74. |
| M/s Shree Om Steels v. Addl. Commissioner Grade-2 | Writ Tax No. 1007 of 2022 | Reaffirmed Metenere Ltd.; tax on excess stock to be determined under Sec. 73/74, not Sec. 130. |
| Metenere Limited v. State of U.P. | Earlier Allahabad HC ruling | Clarified that Sec. 35(6) read with Sec. 73/74 governs unaccounted goods, not Sec. 130 confiscation. |
| Maa Mahamaya Alloys Pvt. Ltd. v. State of U.P. | Allahabad HC | Held that valuation by eye estimation not valid; penalty limited as per Sec. 122; Sec. 130 wrongly invoked. |
Between Fine Lines
For trade and industry, the ruling underscores that mere detection of excess stock during survey cannot trigger confiscation under Section 130. Tax liability, if any, must be determined under Section 73 or 74 following due process. This protects registered dealers from arbitrary confiscation proceedings and reinforces that intent to evade tax is essential before penalty/confiscation can be levied.
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”




