Home Case Laws GST demand order quashed as SCNs were placed only under “Additional Notices...

GST demand order quashed as SCNs were placed only under “Additional Notices and Orders”, leading to violation of natural justice principles

0
294

Case Summary (Structured as per GST Litigation Standards)

Case Details

  • Title: BINSAR Automobiles v. Sales Tax Officer Class II/AVATO, Ward 204, Zone 11, Delhi & Anr.

  • Court: High Court of Delhi, New Delhi

  • Petition No.: W.P.(C) 11308/2024 & CM APPL. 46860/2024

  • Date of Judgment: 06.09.2024

  • Statutory Framework:

    • Section 73, IGST Act, 2017

    • Section 73, CGST Act, 2017

    • Section 73, SGST Act, 2017

  • Category: Natural Justice – Service of Show Cause Notice; Adjudication under Section 73


Facts of the Case

(Paras 1–3)

The petitioner, BINSAR Automobiles, assailed an order dated 09.03.2024 passed under Section 73 of the IGST/CGST/SGST Acts for the tax period April 2018–March 2019. The petitioner asserted that the Show Cause Notices dated 08.12.2023 and 17.12.2023 were never served and were merely uploaded under the tab “Additional Notices and Orders” on the GST portal. Since the taxpayer had no reason or requirement to access that tab, the SCNs allegedly never came to its knowledge. Consequently, the adjudication order was claimed to be in breach of audi alteram partem.


Questions / Issues for Consideration

(Paras 1–4)

  1. Whether uploading SCNs only under the “Additional Notices and Orders” tab without proper service constitutes valid communication under GST law.

  2. Whether the adjudication order dated 09.03.2024 passed under Section 73 stands vitiated due to breach of natural justice.

  3. Whether the matter requires remand following the principles laid down in ACE Cardiopathy Solutions Pvt. Ltd. and Kamla Vohra.


Court’s Observations

(Paras 3–4)

The Bench acknowledged that the petitioner had not accessed the SCNs because they were uploaded solely under “Additional Notices and Orders”, a location where a taxpayer would not ordinarily expect statutory SCNs. The State fairly conceded that the issue is squarely covered by two earlier Division Bench rulings of the Delhi High Court—ACE Cardiopathy Solutions Pvt. Ltd. and Kamla Vohra—where similar non-service under obscure tabs was held to violate natural justice.

Accordingly, the Court accepted that the adjudication order could not stand when the foundational SCNs had not been effectively communicated.


Judgment / Final Directions

(Paras 5–6)

The Court set aside the impugned adjudication order dated 09.03.2024. It permitted the petitioner to file a reply to both SCNs within two weeks, along with supporting documents. The adjudicating authority was directed to grant a personal hearing and pass a fresh speaking order in accordance with law. The writ petition and the pending application were disposed of accordingly.


Case Law Referred & Summary Table

Case Cited Court / Citation Principle Laid Down Relevance
ACE Cardiopathy Solutions Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India & Ors. Delhi HC, Neutral Citation 2024:DHC:4108-DB Uploading SCNs under irrelevant or obscure tabs does not constitute proper service; orders passed without proper notice violate natural justice. Respondents relied on this to concede remand.
Kamla Vohra v. Sales Tax Officer Class II Delhi HC, Neutral Citation 2024:DHC:5108-DB SCNs must be served in a manner ensuring actual or constructive knowledge; mere portal upload under non-standard sections is insufficient. Court followed this precedent to set aside the order.

Between the Fine Lines (Practical Takeaways for Industry)

This ruling reinforces that GST authorities must ensure proper and accessible service of SCNs. Uploading notices in hidden or rarely-used GSTN tabs will not satisfy statutory service requirements. Any adjudication order based on such ineffective service is vulnerable to being quashed. Taxpayers should routinely monitor all GST portal tabs, but adjudicating authorities carry the primary burden of ensuring transparent communication.

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY