Home Case Laws GST Demand Order Set Aside for Lack of Hearing and Visibility of...

GST Demand Order Set Aside for Lack of Hearing and Visibility of SCN

0
253

Case Title: Singhal and Sons v. Sales Tax Officer Class II/AVATO, Ward 16 & Ors.
Court: Delhi High Court
Petition No.: W.P.(C) 7244/2025
Category: Procedural Infirmity – Show Cause Notice & Natural Justice
Date of Judgment: 27th May, 2025
Relevant Sections: Section 73 & Section 168A of CGST Act, 2017
Relevant Notifications: 56/2023-Central Tax; 56/2023-State Tax


Facts of the Case (¶2–¶7)

  • The Petitioner challenged an order dated 25th August, 2024, arising from a Show Cause Notice (SCN) dated 16th May, 2024, issued by the Sales Tax Officer (AVATO) (¶2).

  • The petitioner also challenged the constitutional validity of Notifications No. 56/2023-Central Tax and No. 56/2023-State Tax for being allegedly issued without valid GST Council recommendations (¶3).

  • The SCN was uploaded only under the “Additional Notices” tab on the GST portal, which the petitioner claimed did not come to its notice (¶6).

  • Despite a reminder notice on 11th July 2024, the petitioner did not file a reply or appear for the personal hearing on 22nd July 2024 (¶6).

  • The impugned order was a non-speaking order that proceeded solely based on non-response and ex parte conclusion (¶7–¶8).


Question(s) in Consideration (¶4–¶5)

  1. Whether the impugned GST demand order suffers from procedural impropriety and denial of natural justice.

  2. Whether the petitioner was given a fair opportunity to respond to the SCN, especially considering the notification visibility issue on the GST portal.

  3. Whether the challenge to the vires of Notifications 56/2023-Central & State Tax should be adjudicated now or await the Supreme Court’s decision in SLP No. 4240/2025.


Observations of the Court (¶9–¶14)

  • The order lacked reasoning and failed to provide a fair opportunity for the petitioner to respond, thus violating principles of natural justice (¶9).

  • The SCN was uploaded in the “Additional Notices Tab”, and the Court referred to similar cases (e.g., Neelgiri Machinery, Satish Chand Mittal, Anant Wire Industries) where such procedural gaps led to remand for fresh adjudication (¶9–¶10).

  • The Delhi High Court emphasized the importance of procedural fairness over rigid portal-driven defaults (¶9).

  • Since the petitioner was unable to file a reply or attend hearing due to notification access issues, the matter deserved to be remanded (¶10).

  • The Court declined to rule on the constitutional validity of the Notifications as the same was sub judice before the Supreme Court in SLP No. 4240/2025 (¶13).


Judgment of the Court (¶11–¶15)

  • The impugned order was set aside.

  • Petitioner was granted time till 10th July, 2025 to file a reply to the SCN.

  • Adjudicating Authority directed to grant personal hearing with intimation through both email and mobile.

  • A fresh adjudication order to be passed after considering reply and hearing (¶11–¶12).

  • The issue regarding the validity of Notifications 56/2023 was left open pending Supreme Court adjudication (¶13).

  • Petition disposed of with liberty to access the GST portal and exercise legal remedies (¶14–¶15).


Between Fine Lines

  • The GST demand order was quashed as the SCN was hidden in a less visible portal tab, and no fair hearing was conducted.

  • The Court emphasized fairness in tax proceedings, especially in digital environments.

  • Orders must be reasoned; procedural lapses like non-speaking orders or ex parte proceedings weaken enforceability.

  • The issue of GST deadline extension via Notification 56/2023 remains undecided, pending Supreme Court judgment.

  • Taxpayers must be given adequate and effective means to respond before liability is crystallized.


Summary of Referred Cases

Case Name Citation Summary Verdict
DJST Traders Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India W.P.(C) 16499/2023 Lead case challenging Notification 56/2023 on vires grounds Pending before SC
M/s HCC-SEW-MEIL-AAG JV v. Asst. Commr. of State Tax & Ors. SLP No. 4240/2025 Central challenge to Notification 56/2023 and extension of limitation under Section 168A Pending before SC
Neelgiri Machinery v. Commissioner, DGST W.P.(C) 13727/2024 Remand due to SCN visibility issue on GST portal Order set aside, remand directed
Satish Chand Mittal v. Sales Tax Officer SGST Order dated 9th Sept 2024, Delhi HC Non-service of SCN via proper channel led to ex parte order Remand directed
Anant Wire Industries v. Sales Tax Officer W.P.(C) 17867/2024 SCN served via obscure portal tab; fair opportunity denied Order set aside
ACE Cardiopathy Solutions Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India 2024:DHC:4108-DB Recognized visibility issue of ‘Additional Notices & Orders’ tab on GST portal Order set aside, remand for reply
Kamla Vohra v. Sales Tax Officer Class II/Avato Ward 52 2024:DHC:5108-DB Similar issue of portal tab miscommunication; ensured fresh hearing Re-adjudication ordered

LEAVE A REPLY